Sheetz - Middletown

American, Mexican, North American
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Sheetz

Sheetz
2.9 / 5 (129 reviews)

Menu

On this Webpage, you will find the comprehensive menu of Sheetz from Middletown. At the moment there are 11 meals and beverages available.

Sheetz in Middletown, Pennsylvania is a popular American restaurant with an average rating of 3.5 stars. Visit us between 12:00 AM and 11:59 PM this week. For inquiries or reservations, please call (717) 944-2535. Explore our menu and compare to other nearby options like Dunkin' and Auntie Anne's. Share your dining experience with us by leaving a review!.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Dawn

Images

Sheetz Food Sheetz Food Sheetz Food Sheetz Food Sheetz Drink Sheetz Food Sheetz Menu Sheetz Menu

Feedback

★ 2.9 / 5 from 129 reviews

This Sheetz location offers competitive fuel prices and convenient features like app payments and bagged ice. However, it shows inconsistent cleanliness and service standards. Several visitors reported filthy restrooms, spider-infested pumps, and overflowing trash, detracting from the overall experience. Customer orders are frequently mixed up or incomplete, especially in the evenings, leading to frustration. On a positive note, the manager, Nate, received praise for personally addressing customer concerns and providing helpful assistance. While the location has potential, improvements in hygiene and order accuracy are necessary to enhance its reputation and customer satisfaction.

joe-hoover-fox8901
06.09.2024

I stopped by for lunch and, while I enjoyed the custom spicy chicken sandwich and the rest of my meal, I feel like I could have found a cheaper option elsewhere.

I try to avoid posting reviews, but this place has messed up my order countless times and I feel I?m just spending extra for less. Don?t come here in the evening! They will for sure mess something up! Today I ordered a cheesesteak sub with double provolone, double meat, peppers, onions, salt, pepper, and toasted. What I got was a toasted roll with two pieces of unmelted provolone, no onions, no peppers, single serving of steak, no salt, no pepper. Unbelievable!!! Though it is, because it happens consistently. ?

My Uber driver was fast and efficient but the fact that you made my milkshake well before she arrived is dumb. Why not make shakes and such the last thing you make when doin an order ? Waste of $5.

dawn-innerst
06.09.2024

I visited this Sheetz location and had a really disappointing experience. First, the restrooms were filthy and didn't even have toilet paper. Then, I noticed that employees had their girlfriends and friends hanging out in the aisles, dancing. The outside was just as bad—while I was at pump 3, I found the pumps covered in spider webs and lost track of how many huge spiders were crawling around. There was trash overflowing from the bins as far as I could see. Overall, this is not a well-run business, and I definitely won't be returning to this Sheetz again!

jackie-shepard-tree1
06.09.2024

The manager, Nate, intervened to address some rude individuals who were bothering me while I was inflating my tires. He made sure they left me alone and even assisted me in filling my tires correctly. It reminded me of how my dad or grandpa would have handled the situation, given my upbringing around garages. Thank you, Nate!

Menu

  • Apps & Sides

    Boneless Bitez Large
    Boneless Bitez Large

    Choose Your Sauce: Habanero Sauce; Buffalo Sauce; Dr. Pepper BBQ; Spicy Asian Sauce; Boom Boom Sauce; Old Bay; Garlic Parmesan; BBQ Ranch Sauce; Buffalo Ranch Sauce; Buffalo Habanero Sauce; Garlic Old Bay Sauce; Nashville Hot; No Sauce.

    $8.9
    Burger Sliderz
    Burger Sliderz

    Default Topping: Slider Bun. Default Topping: Burger.

    $3.4
  • Melts

    Carved Turkey Melt
    Carved Turkey Melt

    Choose Your Bread: Pretzel Roll; Croissant; Everything Bagel $0.55); Plain Bagel $0.55). Default Topping: Carved Turkey. Default Topping: Toasted.

    $6.0
  • Burgerz

    Made To Order Burger
    Made To Order Burger

    Default Topping: Burger. Choose Your Bread: Waffle $0.50); Sliced Sourdough; Traditional Bun; Tortilla Wrap; Croissant $0.55); Plain Bagel $0.55); Pretzel Roll $0.55); No Bread; Everything Bagel $0.55). Default Topping: Toasted.

    $4.5
  • Chicken

    Chicken Tender Sub Half
    Chicken Tender Sub Half

    Default Topping: Chicken Tenders. Choose Your Bread: White Sub Roll; Honey Wheat; Pretzel Roll; Flatbread; No Bread.

    $5.5
  • Appz & Sidez

    Mto Potato Skinz
    Mto Potato Skinz
    $6.0

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.