Sheetz - Middletown

I stopped by for lunch and, while I enjoyed the custom spicy chicken sandwich and the rest of my meal, I feel like I could have found a cheaper option elsewhere... read more I stopped by for lunch and, while I enjoyed the custom spicy chicken sandwich and the rest of my meal, I feel like I could have found a cheaper option elsewhere.

I try to avoid posting reviews, but this place has messed up my order countless times and I feel I?m just spending extra for less. Don?t come here in the evenin... read more I try to avoid posting reviews, but this place has messed up my order countless times and I feel I?m just spending extra for less. Don?t come here in the evening! They will for sure mess something up! Today I ordered a cheesesteak sub with double provolone, double meat, peppers, onions, salt, pepper, and toasted. What I got was a toasted roll with two pieces of unmelted provolone, no onions, no peppers, single serving of steak, no salt, no pepper. Unbelievable!!! Though it is, because it happens consistently. ?

My Uber driver was fast and efficient but the fact that you made my milkshake well before she arrived is dumb. Why not make shakes and such the last thing you m... read more My Uber driver was fast and efficient but the fact that you made my milkshake well before she arrived is dumb. Why not make shakes and such the last thing you make when doin an order ? Waste of $5.

I visited this Sheetz location and had a really disappointing experience. First, the restrooms were filthy and didn't even have toilet paper. Then, I noticed th... read more I visited this Sheetz location and had a really disappointing experience. First, the restrooms were filthy and didn't even have toilet paper. Then, I noticed that employees had their girlfriends and friends hanging out in the aisles, dancing. The outside was just as bad—while I was at pump 3, I found the pumps covered in spider webs and lost track of how many huge spiders were crawling around. There was trash overflowing from the bins as far as I could see. Overall, this is not a well-run business, and I definitely won't be returning to this Sheetz again!

The manager, Nate, intervened to address some rude individuals who were bothering me while I was inflating my tires. He made sure they left me alone and even as... read more The manager, Nate, intervened to address some rude individuals who were bothering me while I was inflating my tires. He made sure they left me alone and even assisted me in filling my tires correctly. It reminded me of how my dad or grandpa would have handled the situation, given my upbringing around garages. Thank you, Nate!