Midtown Pizza - Middletown

#1 - Vegetarian - Middletown, Pizza, Italian
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.
Reservation
Reservation request for Midtown Pizza.

Midtown Pizza

Midtown Pizza
2.8 / 5 (171 reviews)

Description

We have been operating since 1986 and take pride in our fresh ingredients and house made Italian bread and subs. Our customer favorites include traditional and gourmet pizza, homemade pastas, appetizers, hot and cold subs, wraps, burgers, and fresh breads. Come visit us and experience great food made the old Italian way, with top quality and friendly service. Be sure to ask about our daily food and bar specials, and don't forget that we now deliver beer both domestic and import 6/12 packs are available. Call us at 717 944 2195 to place your order today!.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: shakie

Reservation request for Midtown Pizza

Feedback

★ 2.8 / 5 from 171 reviews
shakie-pete
26.10.2024

I just try to order over the phone and the guy got mad and hung up the phone because I asked him if he just started working there because he kept going back to ask if they had or sell what I was ordering. I was working with him until I asked him that. I guess I hurt his feelings.

at-home-with-tina-2
26.10.2024

Little to no flavor. Personally wasn't impressed.

amanda-voshell
26.10.2024

I visited for the first time and ordered a toasted ham and cheese sub along with an Italian sub. The food was fantastic! The toasted sub was perfectly toasted and didn’t hurt my mouth when I took a bite. The flavors were incredible. As for the music, I couldn’t understand the lyrics, but it sounded great. The price was reasonable too—just $17 for two subs!

luis-fernando-alvare-13
26.10.2024

The worst place you can come for food.. ??

monica-rivera-fox092
26.10.2024

Quality of the food is great. The service is great. They will go above and beyond to meet your expectations with the meals and service. Family friendly atmosphere. Will come here again and definitely recommend.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.