Righteous Slice - Rexburg

#13 - Pizza - Rexburg, Italian, Vegetarian Friendly
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Righteous Slice

Righteous Slice
4.6 / 5 (3601 reviews)

Menu

On this Homepage, you will find the comprehensive menu of Righteous Slice from Rexburg. At the moment there are 113 meals and beverages available.

Righteous Slice offers an eclectic experience in Rexburg, with a vibrant ambiance and a diverse menu. While many patrons rave about the unique pizza flavors and quality toppings, others lament the inconsistencies in preparation, citing issues like soggy crusts and raw dough. The vegan options, such as the Garden Sandwich, leave something to be desired unless paired with extra sauces. However, the restaurant's friendly service and reasonable prices contribute to its appeal. Despite varying opinions on the food quality, there's no denying the potential for greatness at this local gem, making it worth a visit for any pizza enthusiast.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Tyler

Images

Righteous Slice Food Righteous Slice Food Righteous Slice Food Righteous Slice Food Righteous Slice Drink Righteous Slice Inside Righteous Slice Food Righteous Slice Drink

Feedback

★ 4.6 / 5 from 3601 reviews

Was Anonym at Righteous Slice a mag?
Some of the most popular options include the Godfather, The Sting, and Praise the Lard, and I can see why they are favorites. Additionally, the fruity dessert pizza completely amazed me! I highly recommend it—definitely a 10 out of 10. I found it so delicious that I couldn't stop eating it! The management deserves special mention; I've never been treated with such warmth and care. The restaurant is impeccably clean,... View all feedback.

What Anonym dislikes about Righteous Slice:
The vegan garden sandwich is a bit on the dry side, so I recommend asking for an extra side of marinara or pesto to go with it. They also offer a customizable vegan pizza without cheese; just make sure they don't charge extra for substituting vegetables in place of meat. View all feedback.

malina-rodriguez
18.11.2023

The thin crust, brick oven baked flavor of these pizzas is one of the best in Rexburg! One of my menu favorites is the Bee Sting. The only disappointment I experienced at Righteous Slice was them saying they were out of ranch. They told me a couple times that their ranch supplier fell through, which is unfortunate when they have some of the best ranch in Rexburg too. The wait has never been significantly long, and I never have to wait too long to order. Prices are decent for the quality of food . I definitely find myself coming back here often. Parking: Parking is limited in front of the business, as it is on a corner of a strip of businesses. There is more customer parking behind the business, but it is often 50-90% of the way full during typical meal hours (Lunch and dinner). Service: Dine in Meal type: Lunch Price per person: 10–20 Food: 5 Service: 4 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Pizzas, Bee Sting, Margherita Pizza, Bee Sting Pizza, Margherita, Dessert Pizza Parking space: Somewhat difficult to find parking Parking options: Free parking lot, Free street parking

claire-taylor-snake2
18.11.2023

SUPER good pizza. I was very pleasantly surprised at how good it was Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

dallin-maddock-2
18.11.2023

This is the best Pizza restaurant in the Snake River Valley. In a desolate land of delicious pizza drought Righteous slice is a fountain of cold water. Their different pies are well thought out and I’ve tried almost all of them. They cook it fast in a true pizza oven. The toppings are high quality and fresh. The prices are quite reasonable and portions are large to feed the hungry college kids.The people that work here make other places in town feel disorganized and unfriendly with their 5 star service. I love Righteous Slice and think everyone should give it a try. Service: Dine in Meal type: Lunch Price per person: $10–20 Recommended dishes: Pizzas

tyler
17.03.2025

The absolute best pizza in all of Idaho! They import all ingridents from Italy! The pizzas are hand made to order and 100% fresh everytime. We ordered just a standard pepperoni pizza to try for the first time and it was so delicious and flavorful! My whole family devoured the entire thing in a short sitting! It was so intensely flavorful and so so so good! I can not say enough good things about their pizza, willing to drive 45 mins everytime I want pizza it is so good! If you haven’t tried their pizza, you are surely missing out. They also have fresh squeezed lemonade! So good! And the prices were very fair for everything being imported and authentic Italian ingredients. This place can not be beat for quality, price, and service! The pizza is even good next day reheated! Please stop in and give this place a try, you won’t regret it. It also has some pretty awesome views with the second floor seating! Enjoy! I know we did! Dietary restrictions: Vegetarian pizza options. Kid-friendliness: Great food for kids, my son devoured this pizza. Wheelchair accessibility: Completely accessible on bottom floor.

josh-brink-2
17.03.2025

Great food and friendly staff not much I could complain about Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $10–20 Food: 5 Service: 4 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Three Meat Pizza

  • Righteous Salads

    Spud Harvest
    Spud Harvest
  • Signature Pizzas

    Sunshine In My Soul
    Sunshine In My Soul
    Big Intent
    Big Intent
    Chef Igata
    Chef Igata
    The Star Witness
    The Star Witness
    The Katie Kay
    The Katie Kay

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.