Reviews - Righteous Slice
Reviews summary
Righteous Slice offers an eclectic experience in Rexburg, with a vibrant ambiance and a diverse menu. While many patrons rave about the unique pizza flavors and quality toppings, others lament the inconsistencies in preparation, citing issues like soggy crusts and raw dough. The vegan options, such as the Garden Sandwich, leave something to be desired unless paired with extra sauces. However, the restaurant's friendly service and reasonable prices contribute to its appeal. Despite varying opinions on the food quality, there's no denying the potential for greatness at this local gem, making it worth a visit for any pizza enthusiast.
Was Anonym at Righteous Slice a mag?
The pizza was amazing! The Godfather pizza is a great choice! However, the lack of unsecured windows on the second floor was, frankly, disappointing. Edit: Thank you for your reply! I agree, the windows were incredibly safe. That is my only complaint. View all feedback.
What Shelby Vasas dislikes about Righteous Slice:
I enjoyed the ambiance of the restaurant, but the pizza left a lot to be desired. It was quite doughy and too thin for my taste. The toppings were of good quality, which I appreciated, but overall, I wasn't impressed with the wood-fired pizza. However, the price was reasonable for the portion size, which I liked. View all feedback.
Reviews from various users
Last update : 17.03.2025
The best pizza I’ve had in a long time!! Taste like the pizza I ate in Paris!! Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $30–50 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Three Meat Pizza
Great Pizza! The Nutella desert pizza is to die for! Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $20–30 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Three Meat Pizza, Nutella
The closest thing to real NY pizza around! The crust is perfectly chewy, with a touch of char, and a great sauce! Service: Dine in Meal type: Lunch Price per person: $1–10 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Margherita Pizza
My girlfriend and I were in town and stopped by this place. The staff was all amazing and friendly. We tried a couple of different pizzas and they were all really good. Did a slice of the New York style peperoni and I will be ordering one to go and enjoying another with friends and family. Great job everyone Service: Dine in Meal type: Lunch
I went with some friends and we really enjoyed our visit. The pizza we had was great. Unfortunately, I don't remember the name but it had sausage and red onion. The New York size was about right for the 3 of us. Also, the staff were very friendly and open to answering any questions we had to ask them. Would definitely recommend it to anyone who was thinking about trying it. It's a little pricey for just 1 person, but if a couple of people wanted to split 1 big pizza, I would say this is a good option.
Last update : 22.05.2024
This restaurant offers a wide range of options, catering to specific dietary preferences like vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free. They also allow for meal customization, which was a great touch. It was wonderful to have so many choices to choose from.
The vegan Garden Sandwich at this restaurant can be a bit dry, so I recommend asking for an extra side of marinara or pesto to enhance the flavor. If you're interested in a custom vegan pizza, be sure to request it without cheese, and confirm that they won’t charge you extra for substituting additional vegetables in place of meat.
Last update : 29.08.2023
Must go place while in Rexburg! First time visiting this little town and was gladly surprised to find a good handful of places where families and friends can grab a good meal.Yes, this is one of those handful of places!Location: Rexburg is small, by default your are always close. Having said that, this is in a great spot downtown where multiple other stores, shops, and business are located.Food: when you walk in and find out they have two different ovens, that’s very impressive for any restaurant (let alone a small town .One of their ovens focuses on New York style pizza, so they offer a list of options to choose from, can make a custom order or pizza by the the slice.The second oven (and in my opinion the star of the show! is a an Italian Neapolitan oven (fire oven with all the care from their staff once pizza was done, I noticed they make sure it had a few burnt spots, and they check the bottom to make sure it’s cooked throughout very good craftsmanship.We’ll definitely be coming back next time we are in town when visiting our daughter attending BYUI and get the shakes which apparently are amongst the best in town.The only reason it’s not a 5 star is pricing. For place I feel like it’s slightly overpriced but might be a marketing strategy to set a standard. Would be interesting if they test lower price points.
I’ve never been disappointed with Righteous Slice. Their food is always so amazing, and the service is great at well. They have a second floor so it doesn’t feel crowded and it makes the ambience even better. Regardless of it being busy, the food was quick and delicious. I love how kind the employees are and to top it off even the owner of the restaurant was making the pizzas!! So awesome.We will be back!
We went here after reading about all the awards they had won but really it was just okay. Their pizzas only come in a single size if you want their specialty pizzas which is really strange and means you have to order 6 or so pizzas for a normal size family. We tried several different kinds of pizza (because we had to order 6 pizzas) and none of them were great but none of them were bad either. Staff were friendly but nothing exceptional. Music choice didn’t seem like the music I’d play in a restaurant. Definitely won’t be my go to pizza place but I wouldn’t fight if others wanted to come here.
The food was absolutely and completely unacceptable. Should not have been served. Raw dough, burnt bottom, burnt crust. Ashe all over the pizza from the oven. Too much sauce, puddles of liquid made the whole pizza soggy. Almost no flavor, just mush. The only upside was the pepperoni. It was actually disgusting and it cost me 22 dollars with a runny milkshake. I would have spent half that just to not eat there.
The pizza here was fantastic! It wasn't extremely greasy and the dough size was perfect. Not too thick or thin. It took about 15 minutes for our pizza to be prepared which wasn't too bad. The workers were all really nice and friendly and one of them took the time to ask how our meal was. I would definitely come here again if I visit Rexburg in the future.
Last update : 08.05.2023
You have a vegan garden sandwich that is somewhat dry, ask for an additional page of marinara or pesto with this. You can have a custom vegan pizza minus cheese (make sure they are not extra for adding vegetables instead of meat.
Staff is always so fun and courteous. The shakes are SO good! And the pizza tastes delicious, like it actually has real ingredients. Seriously love this place.
The pizza was amazing! The Godfather pizza is a great choice! However, the lack of unsecured windows on the second floor was, frankly, disappointing. Edit: Thank you for your reply! I agree, the windows were incredibly safe. That is my only complaint.
We loved everything about this place! Our food was delicious and was ready and served to us just as we made it to our table to sit down! The ingredients are so fresh and the flour for the dough, we were told by the owner, comes directly from Italy! Even though we ate it all and were quite full, we did not have that heavy stuffed feeling! Our friends that are from Italy accompanied us and had told us how amazing the pizza was and how authentic and similar it was to the pizza they enjoyed in Naples, Italy! We will be going back often!!!
Some of the most popular options include the Godfather, The Sting, and Praise the Lard, and I can see why they are favorites. Additionally, the fruity dessert pizza completely amazed me! I highly recommend it—definitely a 10 out of 10. I found it so delicious that I couldn't stop eating it! The management deserves special mention; I've never been treated with such warmth and care. The restaurant is impeccably clean, making it an ideal setting for date nights. The service is friendly, and our pizzas arrived at the table exceptionally quickly. Overall, a fantastic experience!
