Pizza D'amore - Queens

#16 - Pizza - Queens, Italian, Salad
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Pizza D'amore

Pizza D'amore
3.7 / 5 (970 reviews)

Description

This restaurant presents a stark contrast in experiences, with some patrons raving about the delicious pizza and commendable garlic knots, while others lament overcharging practices and poor food quality. Reports of rude staff and disappointing dishes, such as tasteless pasta and misdelivered orders, create a sense of frustration among customers. Despite a few loyal fans who appreciate the newer offerings, the restaurant’s negative reviews raise serious concerns about consistency and customer care. Ultimately, prospective diners may want to proceed with caution when considering their next meal here.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Laura

Feedback

★ 3.7 / 5 from 970 reviews
laura
02.05.2024

I ordered two pepperoni corners, and they were incredibly spicy—almost too hot to handle. When I called to express my concern, the staff was rude and said I should have known what to expect when I purchased them. It’s surprising how they think they can read my mind! I definitely won't be returning as a local customer again.

matthew-diaz-3
02.05.2024

I've only ordered the grandma slice with pepperoni and it was so good! The service was great.

ruben117-m777
02.05.2024

After many years of enjoying Ciro's next to Citibank, which remains my favorite pizza spot in Rockaway, I decided to check out this new place. I had never been there before, so I was curious to see what it was like. Upon entering, I asked the woman behind the counter how much a slice of pizza was. To my shock, she said it was $3.50 for just one slice. You've got to be kidding me! This is Rockaway, not Manhattan—where you can still find pizza for 99 cents. It feels like they're just playing games. Plus, the pizza itself tasted like frozen DiGiorno from the grocery store. I would definitely recommend staying away from this place.

mohamed-alzoubeir
02.05.2024

Pizzas good, but they charged me $1 for marinara sauce with my order of garlic knots. Thats like ordering french fries and getting charged for the ketchup

hermiston-phoebe
29.06.2022

Have been going to this pizzeria for years , usually Everytime I go to the beach with my family . The pizza here is great Everytime we come . Also try their garlic knots they are amazing ! . It's very small so they have a few tables to eat inside , they do have a bathroom which is very clean .

FAQ

The second closest stop is MTA-Beach 105th St, located 982 meters away.

You can also pay for your dishes with the common credit cards.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.