Catfish Annie - Payson

American, North American, Delivery Services
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.
Phone
You can call the restaurant via +19289782537

Menu

Here you will find the menu of Catfish Annie in Payson. At the moment, there are 18 menus and drinks on the list.

Catfish Annie in Payson, AZ, is a revered American restaurant featuring a glowing average rating of 4.7 stars. Discover what fellow diners have to say about their experiences at Catfish Annie. If you're interested in the restaurant's current activity level or wish to make a reservation, feel free to call (928) 978-2537. For those seeking similar culinary adventures, consider exploring the offerings at Chinese Thai Restaurant and The Mad Hatters Antiques and Tea. If you've visited Catfish Annie, we invite you to share your review!.

Last update: 11.12.2025 from: Larry

Images

Catfish Annie Outside Catfish Annie Inside Catfish Annie Drink

Feedback

★ 4.4 / 5 from 320 reviews

Nestled inside a gas station, this hidden gem offers exceptional Southern and Cajun cuisine with a warm, welcoming atmosphere. Every dish is homemade, from perfectly fried oysters and broasted chicken to grilled catfish and flavorful gumbo. Signature highlights include sweet potato sides, hush puppies, and the irresistible cherry-coca jam served with fresh biscuits. Friendly, passionate owners ensure each meal is fresh, generous, and delicious—making it clear why the restaurant garners rave reviews. Don’t miss their delectable desserts or classic po’boys. Fast, affordable takeout rounds out the experience, promising a return visit for anyone craving authentic, comforting flavors.

elisa57
Elisa 29.04.2023 - 07:18

I ordered the fried catfish with red bean rice as my supplement. The plate came with a fresh, hot house made biscuit the best cherry mouse I ever tasted. The catfish was delicious: crispy outside, juicy tasteful on the inside. Served with an amazing sauce I can't say. Fresh, delicious, inexpensive... my new place. Plus outdoor seating for those with dog friends. Try it!

nelson81
Nelson 29.04.2023 - 07:18

Catfish Annie offers some of the finest Cajun cuisine for your culinary enjoyment! They serve the best fried oysters in the Payson area! Don't miss the po'boy sandwiches filled with catfish, shrimp, or my personal favorite, oysters! Additionally, the desserts are fantastic.

jesse-gutkowski
Jesse 29.04.2023 - 07:18

I had oysters fresh from Washington and tasty fried perfectly. The cherry mouse was from this world, and the chef gave us each one a hint of puppies because I never had one. Everything is done at home (at least as far as I know). My dinner companion had the cat and loved him. It is easy to see why this place gets so good reviews, I still eat my dinner and had to leave this review now because it is so good!

larry-gass
Larry 24.05.2024 - 06:02

I needed propane, so I went to the local gas station. Makes a lot of sense, right? What I didn 't realize that tucked in the back is this little southern-style restaurant. WOW. The best fried chicken! It 's actually called Broasted Chicken on the menu.I was very pleasantly surprised how great this food is.

amy-archer
Amy 24.05.2024 - 06:02

I had some oysters that were freshly sourced from Washington, and they were absolutely delicious—perfectly fried. The cherry jam was incredible, and the chef even gave us each a hush puppy to try since I had never had one before. Everything seems to be made from scratch, at least as far as I can tell. My dinner companion ordered the catfish and really loved it. It's no surprise that this place has such excellent reviews! I'm still enjoying my meal, but I felt the urge to leave this review immediately because it's just so fantastic!

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.