Reviews - Tasta Pizza
Reviews summary
Nestled in Olean, Tasta Pizza offers an eclectic dining experience where the food elicits both praise and criticism. While the pizza has loyal fans, some diners report it lacking in flavor and undercooked. The infamous chicken wings have been described as cold, poorly portioned, or even contaminated, leading to unfortunate experiences. Customer service varies; some appreciate the promptness and friendliness, while others express frustration over long waits and order mix-ups. Despite these inconsistencies, Tasta Pizza remains a beloved local haunt, famous for its affordable meals and vibrant atmosphere, though improvements in cleanliness and quality control are needed.
Was Anonym at Tasta Pizza a mag?
It's always a pleasure to visit this restaurant. The staff is friendly and service is prompt, so there’s hardly any wait. I'm grateful that we have the only location next to Bradford that offers this fantastic place. View all feedback.
What John Lindner dislikes about Tasta Pizza:
Very cold in dining area and the hard Rock headbanging music was terrible,,, pizza was pretty good but needed some flavor, the chicken wings are good but again way too cold in dining area add music sucked Food: 4 Service: 3 Atmosphere: 1 View all feedback.
Reviews from various users
Last update : 14.03.2025
Service: Takeaway Meal type: Lunch Price per person: $1–10 Food: 5 Service: 4 Atmosphere: 4 Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
This is THE Tasta Pizza, okay?! Bradford has a 'Taste-of-Pizza ' Tasta, right? Like it tastes 'of ' pizza...sometimes. NOT Olean, baby. Olean Tasta is the best, hands down. Care. Quality control. They have it down to a science and they dont go coloring outside the lines, lets say. Cheese consistency is perfect. Sauce isnt too thick so you can fill your belly and not have to promptly enter a food coma from the acidity. (Yes, thank you) Sometimes the tables and walls etc in the dining area are a little dirty, so I usually always get to-go, but man they always always knock it out of the park with the pizza. I love grabbing some of the cookies too. Pinball machine inside, if thats your kinda thing. Grab by the slice or a tray. Really cant go wrong.
Best pizza in Olean great staff and owners good pizza and tacos Service: Dine in Meal type: Lunch Price per person: $10–20 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Food was great. Ready for pick up when they said it would be. Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $10–20 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Chicken Wings, Pepperoni Pizza
Service: Dine in Meal type: Lunch Price per person: $1–10 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Soft Shell Taco, 2 Slices Pepperoni Pizza, Taco Salad
Last update : 23.07.2024
The pizza was delicious. It needed more pepperoni which is why I didn't give it 5 stars, but delicious.
1 tray is a BIG pizza! Absolutely delicious ready very quickly.
2 slices and a soda for 5bux.!!! THIN CRUST DELISH~AND THEIR OWN SAUCE. the cheese blends phenomenal. A nice clean establishment. I didnt take a pic cuz it was so good eating it was more important. Sorry about that...
Always great food! Inexpensive and delicious. Quick and friendly service. My kids love it here.
What could be better than their DAILY SPECIAL of 4 slices and a 24 oz soda? You could enhance it by adding one of their tasty subs! Personally, I love their steak sub.
Last update : 30.04.2023
Typically, I find this restaurant to be quite good. However, my recent experience with the large taco salad was disappointing; it felt more like a large salad with a hint of taco. There was a lot of lettuce but very little meat and toppings, so I've definitely had to deduct a star for that. Consistency needs to be a priority.
I've been coming here since my school days when they had their original spot on the street. It never fails to impress. You’re my go-to for lunch whenever I’m in town. The food is fantastic!
While all the menu items here are absolutely delicious, expect a wait in ordering. There's either a line at meal times or you will be ignored till the employees turn around and ask what you want. Where I work, we are required to acknowledge the customer within 3 seconds of them walking up to the counter and apologize if they've been waiting and ask of we can help them. All I wanted was some silverware and waited 10 minutes for the guy to turn around and acknowledge me. I was also not the only person in line.
One of my favorite pizzas. And look really good with all the updates!
I love Tasta Pizza! Although I no longer live in the area, I made sure to stop by when I visited. The pizza I usually have at other places simply can't compare to Tasta Pizza. The service was quick, the staff was very friendly, and the prices are reasonable. They've raised their prices since my last visit, but even though "Dollar Tree" is now "Dollar Tree Plus" at $1.25, it's hard to complain.
