Anthony's - Old Forge

Italian, Seafood, Cheese
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Anthony's

Anthony's
4.6 / 5 (238 reviews)

Menu

A complete menu of Anthony's from Old Forge featuring all 37 meals and drinks can be found here on the menu.

Voted Best Restaurant for 2024, we invite you and your family to experience the flavors of our authentic dishes. Whether you're craving a classic Italian meal or a succulent steak, we look forward to welcoming you for a delightful dining experience. Don’t forget to check our website regularly for special promotions and exclusive deals that you can print out and bring with you! For larger groups, a 20% gratuity will be applied to parties of 6 or more, and we are more than happy to accommodate dietary requests for all menu items. Gift certificates are also available—a perfect gift for food lovers! Please remember, consuming undercooked meat, poultry, or fish may cause illness. We can't wait to serve you!.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Joe

Images

Anthony's Food Anthony's Food Anthony's Inside Anthony's Menu Anthony's Logo Anthony's Inside Anthony's Menu Anthony's Food

Feedback

★ 4.6 / 5 from 238 reviews

Was jeremy bishop at Anthony's a mag?
Fantastic! Idk why it took me so long to finally go there! I'm a local to old forge for 12 years I wish I found it sooner! Best porkchop I've ever had hands down! Please make the porkchop marsla a main menu item! Also some of the best lamb I ever had! Both were specials but should be on main! Clams were perfect also! great cocktails! Oh the deserts where off the chain!! View all feedback.

What Bosco D dislikes about Anthony's:
Italian food tasted more Asian-influenced; could not eat my entree. Server was polite throughout service but did not respond when I indicated that I didn't care for my meal (left all but two bites on the plate). I never expect to not pay for whatever I choose to order, but at least acknowledge the fact that I wasn't able to eat my meal). View all feedback.

philip-shea-2
27.10.2024

Fine dining, a great bar, super friendly staff. Everything I've had there has been superb!

bosco-d-fish13
27.10.2024

Italian food tasted more Asian-influenced; could not eat my entree. Server was polite throughout service but did not respond when I indicated that I didn't care for my meal (left all but two bites on the plate). I never expect to not pay for whatever I choose to order, but at least acknowledge the fact that I wasn't able to eat my meal).

bob-curtis-2
27.10.2024

Always an enjoyable experience...food is excellent....

joe-cimino-2
27.10.2024

Rosemary chicken special is amazing.

rock-h-rabbit5309
27.10.2024

The steak is to die for!!!

  • Seasonal Cocktails

    Arvest Spritz
    Arvest Spritz
    Ran-Apple Margarita
    Ran-Apple Margarita
  • Beer Selection

    New Trail Seasonal 16Oz
    New Trail Seasonal 16Oz
    Forge Irish Stout
    Forge Irish Stout
    Sbc Lager
    Sbc Lager
  • Cocktail Menu

    Pumpkin Spice Latte Martini
    Pumpkin Spice Latte Martini

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.