Salernos Cafe - Old Forge

#15 - Pizza - Old Forge, Cafe, Italian
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.
Phone
You can call the restaurant via +15704579920
Reservation
Reservation request for Salernos Cafe.

Menu

The menu of Salernos Cafe from Old Forge comprises about 89 different courses and drinks. On average you pay about $7.9 for a dish / drink.

Last update: 11.12.2025 from: Margarey

Images

Salernos Cafe Food Salernos Cafe Food Salernos Cafe Food Salernos Cafe Food Salernos Cafe Inside Salernos Cafe Food Salernos Cafe Food Salernos Cafe Food

Reservation request for Salernos Cafe

Enquire Reservation Now

Feedback

★ 4.4 / 5 from 1727 reviews

Was User at Salernos Cafe a mag?
Our first visit to Pizza Capital in the world was absolutely everything we wanted it (with Coronovirus Lockdown expectations) we were sent here by our amazing Nurses @Taylor Moses NICU! (Also the best) We ordered several appts several cuts. ALL were over expected taste. Jalapeno Poppers, with locally cultivated Jalapenos homemade handmade cheese scattered a MUST! Mozzarella Sticks Gooey, Potato pancakes perfectly cri... View all feedback.

What Abby Cowley dislikes about Salernos Cafe:
So disappointed, this used to be the best pizza ever but it’s gone so down hill. We gave Salerno’s THREE changes praying it was a bad day, but sad to say we’re done with this place. It was our family’s favorite pizza and it’s now gotten so bad we’ve had to throw it out, throwing our money in this economy isn’t feasible to anyone. The cheese is never cooked and it’s slimy and so gross, don’t know if they switched bran... View all feedback.

abby-cowley
Abby 05.10.2024 - 08:25

So disappointed, this used to be the best pizza ever but it’s gone so down hill. We gave Salerno’s THREE changes praying it was a bad day, but sad to say we’re done with this place. It was our family’s favorite pizza and it’s now gotten so bad we’ve had to throw it out, throwing our money in this economy isn’t feasible to anyone. The cheese is never cooked and it’s slimy and so gross, don’t know if they switched brands or what but it’s so sad.

john-rivera-tree66
John 05.10.2024 - 08:25

I arrived to this location with 13 individuals for lunch we waited a minute or five for service the waitress told the group that they were under staff. I asked for a menu and said separate check for me I didn’t split bills she copped an attitude about it and repeated that they were understaffed and that I should just split the bill. So I canceled my order and left the restaurant. It’s not the customer responsibility to staff the establishment . So one start is fitting for the service that I received.

shaun-skursky-bush1
shaun 05.10.2024 - 08:25

The wings were good the pizza not good...service was awesome

margarey-kyle-fox403
Margarey 05.10.2024 - 08:25

Traveled an hour and a half just for their pizza. Bought a few so I could freeze them but worth the wait and drive. Best tray pizza in Old Forge, Old Forge pizza is different from your typical pie. Yummy. The cheese, sauce and dough make a scrumptious mouth watering experience.

louis-sebastianelli
Louis 05.10.2024 - 08:25

This place really went down hill. The tray of pizza tastes like a reheat. The waitress seemed like she didn't even want to be there. And it looks like the place needs a good cleaning and a paint job. The service was terrible for the amount of people there.

  • Entrées

    Domestic Provolone, Black Olives, Pepperoncini And Pepperoni Platter
    Domestic Provolone, Black Olives, Pepperoncini And Pepperoni Platter
    $6.5
    Potato Pancakes (12)
    Potato Pancakes (12)
    $4.0
  • Subs 12&Amp;Quot; (Footlong)

    Sausage In Tomato Sauce Parm
    Sausage In Tomato Sauce Parm
    $5.0
    Meatball In Tomato Sauce Parm
    Meatball In Tomato Sauce Parm
    $5.0
  • Pizza

    Red Pizza With 3 Toppings (12 Cuts)
    Red Pizza With 3 Toppings (12 Cuts)
    $17.5
    Red Pizza (1 Cut)
    Red Pizza (1 Cut)
    $1.1

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.