★ 3.0 / 5 (1 reviews)#1 Pizza in Old Forge ItalianPizza Hut
13420 St, 13420 Old Forge, US
★ 3.1 / 5 (72 reviews)#2 Pizza in Old Forge AmericanPizza Hut
St Route 28, Old Forge I-13420, United States
★ 4.4 / 5 (589 reviews)#3 Pizza in Old Forge Chicken WingsDomino's Pizza
North Main Street 213, 18518 Old Forge, US
"Food was great and our waitress was the best."
"Fast and great service! and the staff are so nice!"
★ 4.0 / 5 (537 reviews)#4 Pizza in Old Forge Lunch CheeseDomino's Pizza
405 S Main St, Old Forge I-18518-1671, United States
"It's always great. I'm just expecting food not to be burned. I had problems with the brownies that were burned that they were exchanged to me, blessed..."
★ 4.3 / 5 (477 reviews)#5 Pizza in Old Forge BreakfastCiccone's Pizza
230 Oak St, Old Forge I-18518-1656, United States
"Since I moved to Old Forge a year ago, I've been pretty deceived about the lack of good food here. My husband, who has been an old forge for decades,..."
★ 4.7 / 5 (857 reviews)#6 Pizza in Old ForgeMary Lou’s Pizza
Dunn Avenue 209, 18518 Old Forge, US
"Very friendly staff and excellent Old Forge style pizza"
Mary Lou's Pizza in Old Forge is a delightful spot that showcases the unique Old Forge-style pizza—a thick, stuffed creation known for its delectable...
★ 4.7 / 5 (68 reviews)#7 Pizza in Old Forge Lunch CheeseMary Lou's Pizza
843 S Main St, Old Forge I-18518-1425, United States
"We didn't try anything on the menu that we don't like, but the pizza is really excellent, especially the Sicilian!"
★ 3.3 / 5 (367 reviews)#8 Pizza in Old Forge Pasta ItalianRevello's Pizza Cafe
S Main St 502, 18518 Old Forge, US
"On Sunday afternoon, all the live bands were performing. It would have been better to have another bartender, but I understand that they may be short-..."
★ 4.9 / 5 (287 reviews)#9 Pizza in Old Forge LunchThe New Elio G's Pizza Shop
843 S Main St, Old Forge I-18518-1425, United States
★ 3.9 / 5 (4545 reviews)#10 Pizza in Old Forge Food WineTony Harper's Pizza Clam Shack
New York Highway 28 3062, 13420 Old Forge, US
"Delicious pizza and fun atmosphere! Great selection of beer, too."
**Restaurant Review: A Mixed Bag at Tony Harper’s** Tony Harper’s offers a vibrant atmosphere with scenic views, particularly from its rooftop bar. W...
★ 4.0 / 5 (1 reviews)#11 Pizza in Old Forge ItalianTony Harper's Pizza And Clam Shack
Main Street 3062, 18518 Old Forge, US
#12 Pizza in Old Forge ItalianJhon's Place Italiano
112 S Main St, Old Forge, United States
★ 4.4 / 5 (5095 reviews)#13 Pizza in Old Forge ItalianCafe Rinaldi
South Main Street 426, 18518 Old Forge, US
"The owner was amazing as was the food. 10 out of 10 recommend"
In the heart of Old Forge, a local Italian restaurant offers mixed experiences that spark both admiration and disappointment. Diners rave about the de...
★ 4.5 / 5 (2011 reviews)#14 Pizza in Old Forge AmericanFront Door Diner
3091 Hwy 28, Old Forge, NY, 13420, United States
"Great wings, great pizza, great place for a quick meal!"
The restaurant offers a mixed experience, with highlights including attentive and friendly service, particularly during busy hours, and delicious pizz...
★ 4.4 / 5 (1727 reviews)#15 Pizza in Old Forge Cafe ItalianSalernos Cafe
Moosic Rd 139, 18518 Old Forge, US
"The wings were good the pizza not good...service was awesome"
"Delicious! Extremely friendly staff!"
★ 4.2 / 5 (1094 reviews)#16 Pizza in Old Forge Italian CoffeeCusumano
S Main St 432, 18518-1609 Old Forge, US
"Awesome experience. Love T. J. Fun guy."
"Food was delicious our waiter was super attentive and fun."
★ 3.6 / 5 (1913 reviews)#17 Pizza in Old Forge AmericanSlickers Adirondack Tavern
3132 State Route 28, 13420, Old Forge, United States
"Amazing pizza and wings nice staff and will come back"
Located in Old Forge, this restaurant offers good food and a varied drink menu that many patrons enjoy, including standout items like the French dip s...
★ 3.9 / 5 (762 reviews)#18 Pizza in Old Forge ItalianAdirondack Pizzeria
Main St 3105, 13420-3714 Old Forge, US
"Amazing pizza and wings nice staff and will come back"
At this family-owned restaurant, diners can expect a mix of decent pizza and nostalgic arcade fun, albeit with notable shortcomings. While some patron...
★ 4.1 / 5 (740 reviews)#19 Pizza in Old Forge AmericanAdirondack Pizzeria
Main Street, Old Forge I-, United States
"Sie haben SOME RARE CABINETs HIER CAW, HOWEVER MOST ARE OUT ORDER CAW CAW"
★ 4.6 / 5 (350 reviews)#20 Pizza in Old Forge AmericanBenny's Ice Cream
2933 Rt. 28, Old Forge I-13420, United States
"The employees are always nice and friendly and the ice cream is always delicious. What more could you want?"