Agostini Bakery - Old Forge

#21 - Pizza - Old Forge, American, International
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Agostini Bakery

Agostini Bakery
4.4 / 5 (162 reviews)

Menu

Here you will find the menu of Agostini Bakery in Old Forge. At the moment, there are 6 dishes and drinks on the menu.

Reopened in 2023, this restaurant is a local treasure for pizza enthusiasts, known for supplying top-notch pizza shells to various establishments across the region. With a dedicated and efficient night staff who create a welcoming atmosphere, supporting this business also means supporting community spirit. Customers rave about the deliciousness of their products, often declaring the pizza shells unmatched in quality. Conveniently, the restaurant offers pizza kits for home chefs, blending value and flavor. However, early risers may find it inconvenient that fresh bread isn't available until 8 am. Overall, it's a delightful destination for food lovers.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Robert

Images

Agostini Bakery Food Agostini Bakery Outside Agostini Bakery Food Agostini Bakery Drink Agostini Bakery Menu Agostini Bakery Menu Agostini Bakery Drink Agostini Bakery Menu

Feedback

★ 4.4 / 5 from 162 reviews

Was Fanny Kutch at Agostini Bakery a mag?
Fantastic ppl work here, I enjoy knowing the ppl that work the night shift, they run their layer like a well-oiled machine, so if you want to support local businesses, the ppl that make the dough here are just fantastic! View all feedback.

What Pat Simpson dislikes about Agostini Bakery:
Owner was unbelievable. Had a coupon through local flavor that expired but value of $15 was good until 2026. She refused to honor it. No indoor dining so we didn't use it. Very unreasonable!! View all feedback.

gakankunda-1
27.06.2022

My kids enjoy making their own pizza using the pizza kits provided at this restaurant!

cmertz
27.06.2022

The staff at this restaurant is wonderful. I appreciate getting to know the people who work the night shift. They operate efficiently and smoothly, making it a great place to support local businesses. The people who make the dough here are fantastic!

rusty-luettgen
27.06.2022

The staff at this restaurant are amazing. I appreciated getting to know the people who work the night shift. They operate their shift smoothly and efficiently. If you enjoy supporting local businesses, the staff who make the food at this restaurant are fantastic!

robert-russell-fish4
30.03.2024

The bread here has always been excellent. It's been my understanding this bakery is under new ownership.

dominic-marianacci
30.03.2024

Very helpful ⁰

Full Menu

More information

QR-Code for the menu

QR-Code zur Speisekarte von Agostini Bakery

Suggested nearby restaurants.