Reviews

Overall Total Score
3.9 out of 5
Very good | 11335 reviews

What OpenTable Diner likes about Serafina Broadway:
Food was tasty and that’s about it. Service was all around terrible. They brought the wrong order to my dining companion and for some reason brought my order back too, even though my order was correct. I had to flag down the server to bring my food back over otherwise it was going to sit out until the other correct order was ready?! Waters were never refilled during the meal. Our server never came to check in on us y... View all feedback. What Amin Rawdah doesn't like about Serafina Broadway:
The food is pretty consistent and good … not amazing. The staff is cheerful and helpful. You get served quickly which is great for pre-theater. The salads for some reason get over salted which is a shame. Nothing else was problematic. Prices are higher like everywhere else which makes the place not such a bargain anymore, but for a pre-theater meal in a festive atmosphere (as long as your expectations are moderate) I... View all feedback.

Reviews from various websites

Menu
4.0 ★ from 43 reviews
Kallie
14.09.2021 - 14:58

Great food and device. Pizza Margherita was great as was the pasta Bolognese

Maxine
14.09.2021 - 14:58

Great food, medium location (natural to midtown). Would recommend downtown locations better!;

Dejuan
14.09.2021 - 14:58

Servers were kind but the service was a bit spotty (probably due to Covid challenges in hiring). Pizza was good. Really only negative was the inane music in the...

read more
Kailee
14.09.2021 - 14:58

Excellent experience with great food and great service

Chelsie
14.09.2021 - 14:58

I have been to other Serafina’s. This one is not at the same level. Service was slow and disorganized, food was ok at best. I expect more from Serafina. Won’t b...

read more
Opentable
4.4 ★ from 2365 reviews
scarletfire
01.05.2024 - 14:10

Fantastic experience across the board. Was greeted by a friendly hostess (wish I had gotten her name) who was super accommodating with our table selection. The...

read more
TNYB
30.09.2023 - 17:06

We sat at the corner table on street in tent .. we watched 3 different people trip and fall to the ground on the little hump in the sidewalk. i know that 's the...

read more
localfoodie
30.09.2023 - 17:06

Nice staff, good food and good prices perfect for the area large space with lots of tables

Antonina
30.09.2023 - 17:06

Great meal and loved the Marilyn theme! Beautiful restaurant.

Julie
30.09.2023 - 17:06

Entrees we’re served so quickly we canceled our salad order. We felt very rushed.

Google
4.1 ★ from 1960 reviews
Reggie
21.02.2024 - 15:08

Their carbonara was exceptionally good and definitely worth trying. Highly recommend it!

Daniel
21.02.2024 - 15:08

Everything was perfect to start our new year's eve celebration. The grilled octopus was the best I've ever tasted.

Lina
21.02.2024 - 15:08

Love it. New York at its best in the affordable price range. A must before a Broadway show. Great wine list, a versatile choice of pastas and generous antipasto...

read more
B
21.02.2024 - 15:08

Beautiful inside. We’ve had a lot of Italian in NYC, and this was at the bottom. Thd food just wasn’t great. The dessert options were lacking. The service wasn’...

read more
JOHN
21.02.2024 - 15:08

I had the eggplant parmiggiana. For $24, it did not come with a side of pasta. Overall the food was very good.

Restaurantji
3.7 ★ from 925 reviews
Arianna
21.08.2023 - 09:34

The atmosphere is nice, it is comfortable and spacious, the food is not that good, the pepperoni pizza was bad, it looked like it was from any fast food place,...

read more
Ravit
21.08.2023 - 09:34

Food was a little about average. Wasn't impressed with my burrata and artichoke dish. The cheese was firm in the center and hardly any seasoning on the dish.Pas...

read more
OpenTable
21.08.2023 - 09:34

Food was tasty and that’s about it. Service was all around terrible. They brought the wrong order to my dining companion and for some reason brought my order ba...

read more
Food
21.08.2023 - 09:34

It was a very good meal and the staff was great. The atmosphere was calm and really enjoyable.

OpenTable
21.08.2023 - 09:34

Our table was ready when we arrived and our waiter was amazing. All the staff very attentive and it was a busy night. It was my niece’s birthday and they made i...

read more
Aggregated
4.4 ★ from 10 reviews
Raphaelle
15.09.2023 - 07:33

This is a very beautiful place inside. The sounds from the bustling streets are drowned out and the ambience is really nice. The options on the menu are plentif...

read more
Hugh
15.09.2023 - 07:33

Very nice, intimate atmosphere. Waiter was very nice as well and didn't rush us at all like at some other restaurants. Most importantly the food is amazing. You...

read more
Stanford
15.09.2023 - 07:33

Wow!! We decided to eat here on Friday 8/19/22 because it was located right next-door to the book of Mormon Broadway show we were seeing. What we weren’t expect...

read more
Mark
15.09.2023 - 07:33

Came to Serafina for a quick and light dinner. Service is wonderful here! We arrived without reservation and were seated quickly. The waiter answered all questi...

read more
Dania
15.09.2023 - 07:33

Pasta was really good but the pizza was ok. The patio was nice but they need to upgrade the chairs and tables a bit, the table cloth wasn’t very clean, there we...

read more
Int Restaurants
4.2 ★ from 4865 reviews
Dan
03.08.2023 - 05:58

We went in for dinner, we didn’t have a reservation but we’re seated in five minutes of arrival. We ordered pizza and salad and both came out very fast. The wat...

read more
Serra
03.08.2023 - 05:58

A classic Italian kitchen location, making you feel at home, and their food are not disappointing as well. Great servers. And they don't rush you to finish your...

read more
Navjot
03.08.2023 - 05:58

We ordered penne al arrabiata, pesto spaghetti and one of the fish. Overall the taste was good but the dressing/sauce of the fish was on the sweeter side which...

read more
Emilio
03.08.2023 - 05:58

Great food and presentation! The lasagna was superb. It was week balanced and The cheese was cooked to perfection. The Burrata recipe was not the best ever, lik...

read more
Yelp
3.0 ★ from 701 reviews
Judy
12.06.2023 - 08:53

The reservation was made in advance. We arrived together. We sat right away. There are two universal toilets and one line expected. I came back...

Sylvía
12.06.2023 - 08:53

The food was excellent. the ambiente was very nice and the service was on place. eating is the same over the chain. the meatballs and carbonara are amazing

Joaquin
12.06.2023 - 08:53

Beautiful waitress. Gluten free options delicious! Approved for NYC. We booked it the next time.

Gastroranking-us
3.8 ★ from 466 reviews

Good Rated Restaurants near New York

4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: New York, 123 West 52nd Street, City Of New York, 10019, United States Of America, 10019-6097
"Great experience! Pricey but good. Tables for 2 a close."
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: New York, 160 E. 46th St., New York 10017, United States
"Refined cuisine and service to elevate your evening."
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: New York, 134 Reade St., New York 10013, 10013-3848, United States
"Amazing. Perfect. My favorite place to go. Thoughtful, romantic."
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: New York, 202A Mott St, 10012, New York, US, United States
"Very good Chocolate, special flavors."
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: New York, 100 3rd Ave, 10003, New York, US, United States
"Food and services were great and it was very affordable!! The music was too loud for me though."
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: New York, 1191 First AvenueNY 10065, New York, United States
"Great Job, thanks for the booth..... we had a wonderful evening"
4.6
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.6
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: New York, 306 E 81st St New York, NY 10028, 10028-3937, United States
"Great food great service great hospitality Thank you"
4.7
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.7
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: New York, 165 Duane Street New York, NY 10013, 10013-3336, United States
"Fabulous experience for a big family birthday."
4.9
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.9
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: New York, 18 Cornelia St #1, New York, United States Of America
"Fantastic experience with some of the best service in the city"
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: New York, 251 E. 110th St., New York 10029, 10029-3249, United States
"This is nothing less than a BRILLIANT restaurant. Superb food!"