Pizza Mill - Custer

The pizza was outstanding! The bottom crust was extremely thin, while the edges were rolled up thick, making it an interesting texture. I would suggest using a... read more The pizza was outstanding! The bottom crust was extremely thin, while the edges were rolled up thick, making it an interesting texture. I would suggest using a fork and knife instead of picking it up, as it’s quite delicate. The outer crust was light and flaky, which added to its appeal. The sauce, cheese, and toppings were all delicious. We sampled a supreme pizza and one with just a single topping, and both were excellent. Considering my all-time favorite pizzas, this place might just make it into my top five. I’ll definitely return next time I’m in the area!

We ordered the regular crust Towering Timber (Supreme) pizza, accompanied by a side salad. The salad was average, featuring a pre-packaged dressing. However, th... read more We ordered the regular crust Towering Timber (Supreme) pizza, accompanied by a side salad. The salad was average, featuring a pre-packaged dressing. However, the pizza was fantastic! The sauce and sausage had a nice kick to them, which I really enjoyed. The vegetables were fresh, and the green pepper added a delightful slight crunch. The thin crust struck the perfect balance between crispy and chewy. Our server was friendly and attentive. I would definitely recommend this place!

The owner was extremely rude when I mentioned that the pizza was burnt and requested a new one. She claimed it was because I was an hour late picking it up, and... read more The owner was extremely rude when I mentioned that the pizza was burnt and requested a new one. She claimed it was because I was an hour late picking it up, and then insisted that the pizza was made in a brick oven and she wouldn't make another. When I pointed out that my previous orders hadn’t been charred on both sides, her response was, “I’ll go ahead and refund your money, and we’ll part ways.” Seriously? Part ways? It was just a pizza, not a disastrous date! Very, very rude.

The owner was incredibly rude when I said the pizza was burnt and asked to have another made. Her excuse was because I was an hour late picking it up. Then said... read more The owner was incredibly rude when I said the pizza was burnt and asked to have another made. Her excuse was because I was an hour late picking it up. Then said it?s made in a brick oven and wasn?t going to make another. After saying previous ordersweren?t charred top and bottom, the response she gave was, ? I?ll go ahead and refund your money and we?ll partways.? Seriously? Part ways? It was a pizza, not a date gone bad! Very very rude.

The pizza was fantastic! Crust was very thin on the bottom and rolled up thick on the edge. I'd recommend a fork and knife over picking up the pieces as it's so... read more The pizza was fantastic! Crust was very thin on the bottom and rolled up thick on the edge. I'd recommend a fork and knife over picking up the pieces as it's so thin. The outer crust was very light and flaky, very tasty. The sauce, cheese and toppings weredelicious. We tried a supreme and a one topping and they were both very good. Thinking about other pizzas that are my all timefavorites, this place might crack the top 5. I will be back next time I'm in the area and we'll see if they can replicate theexperience before I cement it in my top 5 but I'll definitely be thinking about it until then. We came on a Saturday afternoonin mid October, they were steady but not busy. Our service was fast, the restaurant and restroom was clean.