Pizza Mill - Custer

#4 - Pizza - Custer, American, North American

Pizza Mill

Pizza Mill
4.1 / 5 (1490 reviews)

Description

Pizza Mill in Custer, SD, is a beloved American restaurant with an impressive average rating of 4.7 stars. Guests have raved about their experiences at this cozy eatery. Today, Pizza Mill will welcome patrons from 11:00 AM to 7:00 PM. Whether you're enjoying an intimate meal for two or celebrating with a larger group, be sure to call ahead to reserve your table at (605) 673-3306. If you’re looking for similar dining options, don’t miss out on Miner's Cup and Subway. Have you visited Pizza Mill before? We invite you to share your thoughts with a review!.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Dudley

Feedback

★ 4.1 / 5 from 1490 reviews
christopher-b-squirr-1
11.11.2023

Fantastic food, Love Salad Wednesdays. Always great service

julie-d-student1
11.11.2023

My favorite place to eat lunch! Great food and excellent customer service.

jamie-w-chef4
11.11.2023

Delicious pizza, great price, and phenomenal people. EAT HERE.

dudley65
05.06.2025

The pizza was fantastic! Crust was very thin on the bottom and rolled up thick on the edge. I'd recommend a fork and knife over picking up the pieces as it's so thin. The outer crust was very light and flaky, very tasty. The sauce, cheese and toppings weredelicious. We tried a supreme and a one topping and they were both very good. Thinking about other pizzas that are my all timefavorites, this place might crack the top 5. I will be back next time I'm in the area and we'll see if they can replicate theexperience before I cement it in my top 5 but I'll definitely be thinking about it until then. We came on a Saturday afternoonin mid October, they were steady but not busy. Our service was fast, the restaurant and restroom was clean.

kuphal-alden
05.06.2025

We had the regular crust Towering Timber (Supreme) pizza, with a side salad. The salad was just ok, with a packaged dressing. But the pizza was delicious! The sauce and sausage was a bit spicy, which I like. The veggies were fresh, with just a littlecrunch to the green pepper. The thin crust was just the right mix of crunchy and chewy. The server was very nice andattentive. Would recommend.

FAQ

The restaurant offers free WLAN for its guests.

The restaurant serves you a choice of gluten-free meals.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.