Tisha's - CAPE MAY

Seafood, Italian, American
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.
Reservation
Reservation request for Tisha's.

Tisha's

Tisha's
4.5 / 5 (20669 reviews)

Description

Tisha's restaurant offers a unique dining experience with great margaritas and exceptional dishes, such as scallops with Curry Risotto and the Pescatore Special. The atmosphere is lively and fun, but some reviewers found the dishes to taste too similar and overcooked. The service received mixed reviews, with some praising the wait staff while others found them inattentive or rude. Overall, Tisha's seems to be a hit or miss for some, but for others, it remains a must-visit dining spot with outstanding food and service.

Last update: 27.05.2026 from: Mark

Reservation request for Tisha's

Submit Reservation Request

Feedback

★ 4.5 / 5 from 20669 reviews
mark-s-smith-forest3
29.06.2025

Swung by Trisha’s while visiting Cape May. Just needed some appetizers to hold us over. The scallops and risotto was terrific. Perfect size for an appetizer! Perfectly cooked scallops. Terrifically made risotto. Good service, but a littleslow (perhaps understaffed. Odd they only sold wine by the bottle and not by the glass. Been here once before and we recall itbeing terrific food and well presented.

miranda
29.06.2025

We have been going to Tisha’s for years and the dining experience never disappoints. There are always several specials to accompany the menu selections that showcase seafood entrees you’d expect for this coastal town. Tonight we had the halibut andscallop specials which were fabulous. The pork and salmon entrees were also superb. We have never had a regretful meal atTisha’s and the outside dining option is perfect for a beautiful summer day.

allison-deinnocentii-2
29.06.2025

I wish this was a five star post because we heard nothing but wonderful things about this place. The staff was beyond friendly and attentive and I loved the atmosphere. The food tasted good, but I feel it could have been better. For example, the chefsspecial was their garden burger but with fried chicken. When it came out … it was literally two chicken tenders on a bun. Andthe fries were just generic. I know that’s a broad statement but I feel like if you have a truffle fries appetizers, the frieswould be a little better quality.

lynn-b-cactus2245
29.06.2025

Excellent! Our server, Sandy, was very attentive. We shared the polenta sausage appy, delish. My hubs I ordered the Filet Poivre and it was cooked to perfection. When I told Sandy I didn’t want the mashed potatoes she loaded me up with extra greenbeans. Nice. Finished a great meal with Key Lime Pie. Highly recommend. Dine al fresco and people watch. FYI: This is a BYOB(which means you can bring a very good wine and save a small fortune)

kayla
22.02.2025

Everything is soo good here!! I love the food!! Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $30–50 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Seafood Risotto

FAQ

Smoking is not allowed in this restaurant.

You can also enjoy gluten-free menus at the restaurant.

The restaurant is accessible and can therefore also be used with a wheelchair or physiological limitations.

The restaurant also takes the common credit cards.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.