Tisha's - CAPE MAY

Seafood, Italian, American
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.
Phone
You can call the restaurant via +16098849119
Reservation
Reservation request for Tisha's.

Menu

The restaurant from CAPE MAY offers 132 different dishes and drinks on the menu for an average price of $25.3.

Tisha's restaurant offers a unique dining experience with great margaritas and exceptional dishes, such as scallops with Curry Risotto and the Pescatore Special. The atmosphere is lively and fun, but some reviewers found the dishes to taste too similar and overcooked. The service received mixed reviews, with some praising the wait staff while others found them inattentive or rude. Overall, Tisha's seems to be a hit or miss for some, but for others, it remains a must-visit dining spot with outstanding food and service.

Last update: 11.12.2025 from: Miranda

Images

Tisha's Food Tisha's Food Tisha's Food Tisha's Food Tisha's Food Tisha's Inside Tisha's Outside Tisha's Drink

Reservation request for Tisha's

Enquire Reservation Now

Feedback

★ 4.6 / 5 from 20098 reviews

Was Janine Petznick at Tisha's a mag?
This was our second time dining here and both times were outstanding. Our server Sandy was wonderful, food was fabulous and the attention to detail phenomenal. Had a great dining experience! I highly recommend. View all feedback.

What Mark S dislikes about Tisha's:
Our meal was sub par! We ordered the special , mussel appetizer . They were chewy , small and were served with a tasteless sauce.My husbands seafood risotto was just ok. Overall very disappointed, we have dined here before and had a positive experience. Unfortunately , last night was not. We probably will not dine here again. View all feedback.

philipj
PhilipJ 14.07.2024 - 07:06

It’s the best overall dining and food experience in Cape May. Highly recommended.

davek
DaveK 14.07.2024 - 07:06

Our meal was outstanding. Halibut with crab for my wife and the scallop special over fettuccini for me. Would prefer to eat outside the next time, but weather dependent. We will absolutely go back our next visit to Cape May.

teddyz
Teddyz 14.07.2024 - 07:06

This is my third visit to this restaurant and I am never disappointed. It offers the best seafood in Cape May with innovative and fresh offerings. The fact that it is BYOB makes it even better. The service is great and the outdoor patio in the back is fantastic when the weather is nice.

miranda
Miranda 29.06.2025 - 20:47

We have been going to Tisha’s for years and the dining experience never disappoints. There are always several specials to accompany the menu selections that showcase seafood entrees you’d expect for this coastal town. Tonight we had the halibut andscallop specials which were fabulous. The pork and salmon entrees were also superb. We have never had a regretful meal atTisha’s and the outside dining option is perfect for a beautiful summer day.

allison-deinnocentii-2
Allison 29.06.2025 - 20:47

I wish this was a five star post because we heard nothing but wonderful things about this place. The staff was beyond friendly and attentive and I loved the atmosphere. The food tasted good, but I feel it could have been better. For example, the chefsspecial was their garden burger but with fried chicken. When it came out … it was literally two chicken tenders on a bun. Andthe fries were just generic. I know that’s a broad statement but I feel like if you have a truffle fries appetizers, the frieswould be a little better quality.

  • Starters

    Thai Salmon And Shrimp
    Thai Salmon And Shrimp
    $35.9
    Pesto Shrimp And Gnocchi
    Pesto Shrimp And Gnocchi
    $31.9
    Cajun Fried Oysters
    Cajun Fried Oysters
    $16.0
  • Antipasti

    Polenta Board
    Polenta Board
    $15.0
  • Entrées

    House Specialty Salad
    House Specialty Salad
    $16.0
  • From The Land

    Pepper Steak
    Pepper Steak
    $48.9

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.