Peter Shields Inn - CAPE MAY
Peter Shields Inn
Menu
The menu of Peter Shields Inn from CAPE MAY contains about 96 different dishes and drinks. On average you pay about $28.8 for a dish / drink.
Peter Shields restaurant received mixed reviews from customers. Some were disappointed in the high prices, subpar food quality, and slow service. Others praised the exceptional service, delicious food, and beautiful ambiance with live music. While some had complaints about specific dishes or experiences, others highly recommended the restaurant for special occasions or date nights. Overall, Peter Shields seems to have a loyal customer base despite occasional issues that may arise during dining.
Images
Reservation request for Peter Shields Inn
Feedback
Was Dennis Eisen at Peter Shields Inn a mag?
Beautiful turn-of-the-century B&B Restaurant located on Beach Ave in Cape May's NJ. Would highly recommend! Ask for Sean; friendly, attentive while not rushing us through View all feedback.
What Bob Kato dislikes about Peter Shields Inn:
Our server, Dillon, was excellent. Personable, knowledgable and efficient. He allowed us to enjoy our time at the restaurant without a rush, something we value. We both enjoyed delicious and excellently prepared meals in a calm, quiet and pleasant atmosphere. The only drawback for us is pricing. We would love to return again and again but the meal prices are prohibitive. PSI will remain our special occasion restauran... View all feedback.
The service was excellent, food presentation and quality were outstanding. Our waiter Peter was a delight Service: 5 Location: 5 Hotel highlights: Luxury, Great view, Romantic, Quiet
I have long wanted to experience dinner at PSI, it more than met my high expectations. A fantastic special occasion dinner. Service: 5 Location: 5
Highly recommend for small weddings! Our wedding dinner at PSI was AMAZING. The food was AMAZING. The service was AMAZING. Everyone was so kind and really went out of their way to help you. They made me feel relaxed and able to enjoy myself. I cannot say enough about Amy, PSI’s event coordinator. She was very responsive and helped me plan the whole dinner. She sent me recommendations and answered every question I had. We had a small wedding of about 30 people and this was the PERFECT location. 100/10.
What an outstanding place and the food was absolutely awesome
Wonderful dining experience! Delicious food! Excellent Service! Dining Ambience with live piano player providing relaxing background music!
Menu
Third Course
Dry Aged Liberty Duck Breast$41.0First Course
Shaved Brussels Sprout Caesar Salad$15.6Second Course
Scallopini Of Jordi Chicken$43.9Simply Grilled
24 Oz. Rib Chop$63.4 Autumn Spice Rubbed Berkshire Pork Tenderloin$44.9 Butcher Choice Prime Filet Mignon$58.6
More information
QR-Code for the menu
This restaurant offers
Suggested nearby restaurants.
★ 4.6 / 5 (20098 reviews)Seafood Italian AmericanTisha's
322 Washington Street Cape May, NJ 08204, 08204-1465, CAPE MAY, United States
"Great night with family Good food terrific service"
★ 4.6 / 5 (3112 reviews)Mediterranean Asian American ChickenYB
314 Beach Ave Cape May, NJ 08204, 08204-1921, CAPE MAY, United States
"Simply put, a very good restaurant with great food and service."
★ 4.6 / 5 (18280 reviews)American Mediterranean American CoffeeWashington Inn
801 Washington Street Cape May, NJ 08204, 08204-1644, CAPE MAY, United States
"We all had a wonderful experience, and the food was exceptional."