Panico's - CAPE MAY

Italian, Bistro, Pizza
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Panico's

Panico's
4.2 / 5 (9749 reviews)

Menu

The menu of Panico's from CAPE MAY includes 111 courses. On average the courses or drinks on the menu cost approximately $13.0. You can view the categories on the menu below.

Panico's is a family-owned restaurant where you can enjoy warm, elegant dining experiences. Our menu features classic and innovative Italian cuisine with Mediterranean influences, including a variety of Macaroni dishes, entrees, and brick oven pizza. Feel free to bring your favorite bottle of wine to complement your meal!.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: MaryD

Images

Panico's Food Panico's Food Panico's Food Panico's Food Panico's Food Panico's Outside Panico's Outside Panico's Drink

Feedback

★ 4.2 / 5 from 9749 reviews

**Dining Experience at Panicos: A Mixed Bag** At Panicos, guests encounter a blend of vibrant culinary experiences and service inconsistencies. While many diners rave about the restaurant's excellent food, cozy atmosphere, and attentive staff, others have faced significant frustrations, including extensive wait times for seating and unresponsive management during emergencies. Some patrons express disappointment over being seated in less desirable areas, questioning transparency in reservations. Despite these issues, loyal customers appreciate the restaurant's unique charm and dedicated owners, often revisiting for its delectable offerings. Overall, Panicos continues to be a polarizing space, balancing moments of delight with occasional service lapses.

I was among several groups of diners who had stayed after 830. we sat 30 minutes after our reservation and there were several parties that were closer to an hour after their reservations. inconvenient, and there was no apology offered. we are not coming back.

Eating was very good. service was also very good. would go back!

Loved our server grace, eating amazing, picking up the ****! best meal ever for 30!$ and we have threatened grace for a run to bring a pizza to a sick friend. she asked if we wanted coffee while we waited! hold her panico! we love this place our favorites in a cold night!

maryd
27.12.2023

Food is always delicious and service is exceptional. We go often and enjoy taking company with us to enjoy.

Great food. Large portions! Busy and loud but service was fast!

  • First Plate

    Spicy Rabe Sausage
    Spicy Rabe Sausage
    $12.0
    Clams Lemon Cello
    Clams Lemon Cello
    $12.0
  • Macaroni

    Baked Tortellini Italian Sausage
    Baked Tortellini Italian Sausage
    $17.9
    Scallops Pomodora Style
    Scallops Pomodora Style
    $27.9
    Shrimp Lemon Bianco
    Shrimp Lemon Bianco
    $24.9
    Garganelle Pinot Grigio
    Garganelle Pinot Grigio
    $27.9

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.