Bagel Basket - Bethlehem

Casual, Salads, Bagels

Bagel Basket

Bagel Basket
4.3 / 5 (3473 reviews)

Description

Nestled in the heart of the city, this restaurant evokes mixed feelings among diners. While some lament recent inconsistencies in their beloved hoagies and bagels, others rave about the substantial portions and quality of the offerings. The My Diya sandwich stands out as a highlight, featuring a crispy chicken breast that has garnered enthusiastic praise. Many guests appreciate the freshly baked bread and a broad selection of drinks, while friendly staff enhance the overall experience. Despite some price concerns, loyal patrons remain drawn to the authentic flavors and delightful ambiance, making it a local favorite.

Last update: 16.04.2026 from: Chelsea

Feedback

★ 4.3 / 5 from 3473 reviews
chelsea-novak-1
16.04.2026

Bagels are $1.10, but WATCH OUT! If you add cream cheese, your total will come out to $4.95! That's some PRICEY cream cheese.... Bagels are good, I had the chive cream cheese on an egg everything bagel (style of bagel, not a bagel sandwich). But I cant believe how much they charge for a glob of cream cheese... The prices for the cream cheese are not displayed anywhere.. and they couldn't print me a receipt. Feeling swindled! The $9.95 sandwich came with a pickle and a side. Macaroni salad was

katherine-diggins-li
16.04.2026

As a foodie from Philly by way of New York, I have a measuring stick I use because I'm very picky when it comes to my food. The bread is baked on the premises and the rest us history. It's pricey but delicious!

devon-lynn-kuntz
16.04.2026

This establishment is a must visit on your bucket list! This scrumptious breakfast sandwich was out of this world. I had them make me a Cheddar Jalapeno Bagel with egg, cheese, and bacon.. It's out of this world delicious, every single bite was filled with joy. If you have never experienced this wonderful creation, I would consider adding this to your list of foods to try!

todd-davies-vine66
16.04.2026

I won't be going here to much anymore. I used to like going here but seems things changed. I went there a few months back and ordered a hoagie it was not made like I asked. I decided to not go there for awhile so I went back again this week. I was not happy that a bagel with sausage egg and cheese was about $7.50. Not worth it to me

thomas-francis-v
28.10.2024

I absolutely love this place! As a native New Yorker, I can confidently say it's as authentic as you can find in the tri-county area. The service is friendly and fast. During lunch, the line...

FAQ

You can watch major sports events on a screen / TV right in the restaurant.

The restaurant also takes credit cards from the common providers as a means of payment.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.