31 Castlegate - York

Cold inside with the radiators being switched off shortly after we arrived. Starter was garlic pizza which we were assured was small but was full size when it a... read more Cold inside with the radiators being switched off shortly after we arrived. Starter was garlic pizza which we were assured was small but was full size when it arrived. Fillet medallions for a main course which were stringy and tough, accompanying sauce was reminiscent of Bisto and altogether poor , monkfish was okay but nothing special decided not to risk desert.

Extremely disappointed. Starter (Terrine) tasteless. Hardly Chef prepared. The chicken main meal was similarly tasteless. Ambience stale. Downstairs room cold.... read more Extremely disappointed. Starter (Terrine) tasteless. Hardly Chef prepared. The chicken main meal was similarly tasteless. Ambience stale. Downstairs room cold. Expected fine dining. Far from it. The waitresses were friendly though. Won't be back.

One of our friends randomly chose this one for us. We had no expectations prior to going in, and we were simply wowed by the food, service and hospitality. It's... read more One of our friends randomly chose this one for us. We had no expectations prior to going in, and we were simply wowed by the food, service and hospitality. It's run by a small crew and we were a group of 10- and they went above and beyond to make sure that we got served to the best of their ability. I would highly recommend it!

Plenty of choice on the menu. Good quality for both food and service. Unhurried relaxing lunch. Fair price. On the basis of this meal booked for a family celebr... read more Plenty of choice on the menu. Good quality for both food and service. Unhurried relaxing lunch. Fair price. On the basis of this meal booked for a family celebration. No problem recommending.

The food at 31 Castlegate is delcious and beautifully plated. Maria was the hostess extraordinaire and an added bonus to the delicious meal. She was warm and fr... read more The food at 31 Castlegate is delcious and beautifully plated. Maria was the hostess extraordinaire and an added bonus to the delicious meal. She was warm and friendly, gave us great suggestions. Kudos to the Chef! We left full and more than happy we close 31 Castlegate for our meal.