Reviews
What Rafael Kerluke likes about Brooklyn Square Pizza:
Really good pizza here the head down was great had large sauce high quality cheese and the dough was crispy on the outside and fluffy in the inside it was great and the regular slice was good and loved the sesame seeds crust it will definitely have again! View all feedback. What Rafael Kerluke doesn't like about Brooklyn Square Pizza:
After waiting over 2 hours for delivery. Had a bone in my chicken parm pizza. Good thing my 4 year old didn't get that piece. Threw the rest away since I was skeptical if there was additional bones. $26 pie in the garbage. My cold antipasto was put between the hot pie and a hot order of meatballs so it was hot antipasto and warm Lettuce and the cheese melted inside the meat. Waste. Every 4 months or so I try to go ba... View all feedback.
Reviews from various websites
20 years living in south jersey with mediocre pizza...finally, finally found great pizza!!!
Great pizza appetizers, etc..perfect, awesome delivery too. All the times I’ve eaten there in Toms River near home I’ve had great food with friendly service too...
read moreI grew up in Brooklyn, and this NJ pizza is as good as the pizza from back home.
Got the upside down square. It's good But, I think if you're in north Jersey bruno's in clifton does it better.
Just No. got the Honeymoon pie. Ate 2 slices, can tell it was an older pizza reheated. Caused diarrhea an hour later. Stay far away.
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreThe pizza is definitely different than I used to, but I definitely enjoyed it. Fluffy, Crispy and a very tasty sauce.
I was there twice. Very friendly atmosphere and pizza was delicious. The pizza has a Brooklyn taste slightly different from North Jersey pizza taste. Good news...
read moreBy far the best pizza in the area. So good that other pizzerias now copy their special pills. I recommend eating as the cake will cool and it will not be so sha...
read moreThe classic square pizza is tomato forward, and the crust has a lovely contrast between an uber-crisp bottom and airy dough. The pizza turned out so much lighte...
read moreAfter waiting over 2 hours for delivery. Had a bone in my chicken parm pizza. Good thing my 4 year old didn't get that piece. Threw the rest away since I was sk...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreReally good pizza here the head down was great had large sauce high quality cheese and the dough was crispy on the outside and fluffy in the inside it was great...
read moreOkay, so a single simple piece is $2.75, $1 more with toppings, but I mean sad, this is now common...$16 for a big cake though... This is a good price while mos...
read moreI got the pizza on my head. It was really good. I have to say I can't eat fat pizza at all. I never liked it, and that was the first I liked. I was impressed. T...
read moreGreat pizza! one of the best I ever had. The staff were so nice and friendly, give them a try you will be disappointed
I tried most of the pizzas in Toms River, Manchester and Brick and this is now one of the best slices on my list. I have become a big fan of Grandma and Margher...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read more