Sal's Italian Pizzeria - Toms River

This is the best pizza I've had in the area! I wanted to try a new place, and I'm definitely going to be ordering from Sals from now on. We got one pizza with half plain and half Hawaiian, and the kids just loved it. The Bruschetta pizza is incredible as well. Both pizzas have a wonderful crunch in every bite. Perfect!

I ordered a Sicilian pizza with meatballs and mushrooms, but it was only topped on one half. The topping side was burnt, while the plain side was slightly undercooked—how does that even happen? The dough and cheese lacked flavor, though the sauce was well-seasoned. As for the hot antipasto, it was a complete disappointment; everything was soggy and tasteless. The pizzeria should be embarrassed to serve such calamari and mozzarella sticks. The eggplant tasted like it had been washed in bleach. The only highlight was the mussels, which I would definitely order again.

Disgusting soggy tasted terrible the toppings were definitely old or spoiled never ordering from here again

The bread was overcooked, which was disappointing because everything else was quite good.

I can only comment on the pizza, and it was excellent. It's the best pizza I've had in my 20 years in Toms River. I regret not trying it sooner... just one slice left!