Reviews
What GeeGee24 doesn't like about The New Caterham Arms:
Went for the carvery on a Sunday. Was horrible. None of us liked the food. Pudding was yuck. Did complain but made no difference. Not cheap in there either. Sorry, won't be going back. View all feedback. What User likes about The New Caterham Arms:
this pub has gone from good to even better! I was previously disappointed at eating, but as a venue it was especially for functions, had a birthday and two abandoning parties here. Eat here now but is definitiw an option and a good one in it. with an experienced chef/restaurant manager, who runs the pub's side, has significantly improved the food, menu selection and service. View all feedback.
Reviews from various websites
This pub has gone from good to even better! I was previously disappointed at eating, but as a venue it was especially for functions, had a birthday and two aban...
read moreGreat eating staff all very helpful and friendly especially leslie dog friendly cannot wait to go back
Best pub in caterham, beautiful personal, atmosphere and amazing eating. big family pig, but also very good for parties!
My son loves this place absolutely and me and his father too. great place to enjoy the whole family. P.s I recommend her carvery! top notch!
We had a lovely Mother’s Day lunch here and the carvery is amazing! Very friendly staff, especially the smiley, chatty Italian waiter we had. Sorry I didn’t get...
read moreNestled in a vibrant locale, this restaurant presents a mixed bag of experiences. Guests have praised the delightful carvery and attentive service during special occasions, while others lament the chaos, insufficient food options, and inconsistent quality. Complaints about undercooked meat and lack of gluten-free awareness contrast sharply with glowing reviews of the buffet and friendly staff. While the venue shines as a party spot with an energetic atmosphere, it struggles with execution, often leading to disappointment. This establishment may best suit those seeking a casual outing, but potential patrons should be prepared for varied dining experiences.
This was a big family celebration that had been booked for months. WHAT A SHAMBLES! No menus no cutlery and even worse no food! We ordered on the app to be told...
read moreI came here with my family on Christmas day and was greeted immediately and was seated down at a table. I was asked for drinks and was given them swiftly. The s...
read moreWMelt in the mouth beef, delicious Vegetables, the cauliflower cheese is the best I had for a long time. Couldn't fault it. The chef brought Gluten free gravy w...
read moreCalled in for Sunday carvery. Food mediocre, only two choices of meat as lamb finished, poor selection of vegetables, carrots (overcooked), peas and cabbage. Ex...
read moreWe ate at this carvery yesterday 16th October 2022 and had booked in advance asking for gluten free meals. The man who served us had no real idea of what was gl...
read moreSadly restaurant has closed. Price per person: £20–30 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 4
A nice, cozy place for dinner with the family, I recommend it Food: 5 Service: 4 Atmosphere: 4
Great pub to watch sports. Food portions were quite small and expensive for what you got, selection was limited. Nice selection of beers and free wifi. Price pe...
read moreDrinks far too expensive!!! Price per person: £20–30 Food: 2 Service: 3 Atmosphere: 2
Price per person: £10–20 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5
My family enjoyed a wonderful Mother's Day lunch at this restaurant, and we were impressed by the fantastic carvery! The staff were very friendly, especially th...
read moreWell been here before and it was great had so much fun Well tonight was a eye opener. Play school was there with there perfect parents not seen...
The food at this restaurant is phenomenal, and the staff is incredibly helpful and friendly. I was particularly impressed with Leslie, who went out of her way t...
read moreGreat pub! Food is always well presented and yummy! Love this pub
We went to the restaurant with our family for Sunday lunch. The food was delicious, the service was excellent, and we all had a great time.