Buffalo Point - Sidney

American, Steakhouse, Burgers
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Buffalo Point

Buffalo Point
3.3 / 5 (31 reviews)

Description

Buffalo Point Restaurant in Sidney offers a mixed dining experience. While some praise its diverse menu, including standout prime rib and chicken fried steak, along with attentive service and an inviting atmosphere, others report inconsistencies. Several diners have experienced poorly cooked steaks, cold food, and subpar service, suggesting possible management changes may have impacted quality. Health concerns and billing issues have also been noted. Despite these critiques, many appreciate the wine selection, kid-friendly service, and ambiance. Overall, Buffalo Point remains a beloved local spot for some, but potential visitors should weigh recent reports carefully.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: sam

Feedback

★ 3.3 / 5 from 31 reviews
sam-mallsworth
28.08.2024

I've been visiting this restaurant since it first opened, but I have to say that my most recent experience was disappointing. There was no one at the entrance to greet us, we didn’t receive any drink refills throughout the meal, and the food was served cold. Overall, the atmosphere felt unwelcoming. I won’t be returning; instead, I’ll take my business to Dude's, where customer satisfaction has always been a top priority.

bob
28.08.2024

Buffalo Point has greatly improved since its change in ownership and management!

alisha
28.08.2024

My husband and I dined here during our visit to town and chose the Valentine's Day special, which was a pound of crab. Unfortunately, just three hours after our meal, I became extremely ill. When I called to inform the restaurant, I received no offer for a refund and not even an apology. I strongly advise you to save your money and opt for McDonald's instead. Additionally, while we were there, two other tables got up and left due to a lack of service. We thought we were fortunate that our food was remembered, but in hindsight, we both wished it had been forgotten.

rzyh28
22.02.2023

Unfortunately, we repeated previous bad experiences. Our filets ordered medium done came to us **** rare. Seems a microwave finished them back in the kitchen. Got charged for what the waitress said was included: a loaded baked potato. The pinch of cheese and bits of bacon are not worth the extra $1.25 charged. With such high prices, one expects nothing but the best. Buffalo Point has failed us three times and we will not return.

antone-yost
21.02.2023

My husband and I dined here while visiting the city and tried their Valentine's Day special, which was a pound of crab. Unfortunately, just three hours later, I became extremely ill. I called to inform the management about it, but there was no offer for a refund or even an apology. I recommend saving your money and avoiding this place—just go to McDonald's instead. During our visit, I also noticed two other tables that stood up and left due to the lack of service. Initially, I thought we were lucky that our food was remembered, but in hindsight, we both wished they hadn't.

FAQ

You can use the WLAN of the place free of charge.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.