Pie95 Pizza - Sharpes

#6 - Pizza - Sharpes, American, Food

Pie95 Pizza

Pie95 Pizza
2.4 / 5 (5 reviews)

Description

Last update: 21.04.2026 from: Karen

Feedback

★ 2.4 / 5 from 5 reviews
karen-f-cat580
31.12.2023

Fantastic pizza and service!!!

karen-f-fern2
31.12.2023

Some of the finest pizza you can find in Jacksonville!

karen-f-chef170
31.12.2023

I had heard about Pie95 Pizza when they used to visit my workplace, but never had the chance to try their food. Now that they’ve opened in my neighborhood, managed by an HOA, I thought it was the perfect opportunity to give them a shot. Unfortunately, when I approached the food truck, the owner greeted me with an unexpectedly rude attitude for no apparent reason (and others have mentioned similar experiences). I decided to walk away and find another place to eat. I don’t plan on coming back and intend to ask my HOA to prevent them from returning.

karen-f-student9705
31.12.2023

The owner was noticeably unfriendly and rude, with little attention to customer service. The pizza was disappointing—I mostly tasted burnt spots and it was overly salty, which masked the flavors of the ingredients. I wouldn’t recommend dining here, either at the restaurant or the food truck. The food from the truck was also below average, and the owner’s poor attitude made the overall experience unpleasant.

karen-f-flower3
31.12.2023

I finally tried the pizza, and it was amazing! They've truly mastered the art of wood-fired pizza—everything looked and tasted even better than I expected. I've been following them on Instagram for years, so I had to give it a try! The owner, Evan, and his staff were incredibly friendly and genuinely passionate about their food, which made for a fantastic experience. I'm excited to visit their new location when it opens on King Street!

More information

QR-Code for the menu

QR code for the menu of Pie95 Pizza

Suggested nearby restaurants.