Sisco Pizza - Rye

At this restaurant, they serve amazing pizza that is easily the best on the island. After trying the pizza, we decided to stay and sample items from the main me... read more At this restaurant, they serve amazing pizza that is easily the best on the island. After trying the pizza, we decided to stay and sample items from the main menu. We were absolutely thrilled with the food - the seafood marinara was the best I've had in years, and my wife declared the gnocchi to be the best she's had in years as well. The food was incredible and the atmosphere of the restaurant was great. We will definitely be returning.

We did not have a reservation during peak season, but they were able to accommodate our party of two adults, two children, and a child in a car seat with a smil... read more We did not have a reservation during peak season, but they were able to accommodate our party of two adults, two children, and a child in a car seat with a smile. The pizza was delicious (except for the chicken on the chicken pizza), and the pasta had a rich flavor with generous portions. The staff provided pencils and paper for the children and had excellent customer service, something we have not experienced before. I can't believe this place only has a rating of 3.4, it definitely deserves a 4!

I have been coming to Rye Pizza Restaurant for some time, when it was sold and taken over by new owners I was concerned that the menu would change. To my deligh... read more I have been coming to Rye Pizza Restaurant for some time, when it was sold and taken over by new owners I was concerned that the menu would change. To my delight the menu wasn't changed but the restaurant decor was. It is much brighter now with a real buzzy feel. Staff (some who stayed from previous owners) are very attentive and friendly. If you are looking for great pizzas and italian food this is the place in Rye to come to.

I requested a gluten-free pizza with no dairy at the restaurant, and the staff inquired if I had celiac disease, a food intolerance, or allergies. They were acc... read more I requested a gluten-free pizza with no dairy at the restaurant, and the staff inquired if I had celiac disease, a food intolerance, or allergies. They were accommodating and prepared my pizza separately.

I requested a gluten-free pizza without dairy at this restaurant. They inquired if I had Celiac disease, intolerance, or allergies, and gladly prepared my pizza... read more I requested a gluten-free pizza without dairy at this restaurant. They inquired if I had Celiac disease, intolerance, or allergies, and gladly prepared my pizza separately.