Make A Cake - Pittsburgh

Grocery, Store, Wine

Make A Cake

Make A Cake
4.7 / 5 (111 reviews)

Menu

On this homepage, you will find the complete menu of Make A Cake from Pittsburgh. Currently, there are 3 menus and drinks available.

Located in the heart of Pittsburgh, Make A Cake is a beloved baking supply store that has garnered a loyal following over the years. Customers rave about the extensive selection of baking essentials, unique items, and knowledgeable staff. While many appreciate the warm, welcoming service and personalized assistance, experiences can vary, especially regarding closing times. Despite occasional misunderstandings, the overwhelming sentiment points to a commitment to quality and community. With decades of loyal patrons, Make A Cake remains a cherished destination for bakers of all levels, promising a delightful experience—if you arrive on time.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: David

Images

Make A Cake Food Make A Cake Food Make A Cake Drink Make A Cake Food Make A Cake Food Make A Cake Food Make A Cake Food Make A Cake Food

Feedback

★ 4.7 / 5 from 111 reviews

Was C K at Make A Cake a mag?
I love this store. I live in Grand Rapids MI and have to stop in every time I get to Pittsburgh. plus, I give my friend Jeana, a list of items and she buys them for me. you have a baking question? I guarantee one of the women will have the answer for you. There are many unique items to try- cookie sheets, cookie cutters, fondant, sprinkles, fillings, etc. This store also makes delicious chocolate candy into so many d... View all feedback.

What Mark Chrystal dislikes about Make A Cake:
I drove an hour to reach the restaurant, knowing that I would arrive just before their closing time of 3pm. I called ahead to ask if they could wait a few extra minutes for me, but no one answered the phone and I had to leave a voicemail. When I arrived promptly at 3pm, the staff refused to open the door for me even though I assured them I knew what I wanted to order and had my credit card ready. They insisted that I... View all feedback.

alan-892
07.08.2023

My wife was ecstatic!!! Wonderful little store with so much in it!!! Candy molds, old time candy from the 60's, 70's and 80's. Melts, flavoring and trays. Anything you need to be a baker. Amazing place!

susan-533
07.08.2023

This restaurant is fantastic for all of your supply needs, and I will definitely be coming back often to shop.

quinn-89
07.08.2023

I have been shopping at Make A Cake for 20+ years. It 's my own personal Cheers , where they know my (and even my children 's) names. They are a wealth of knowledge and can help even the most seasoned pastry professional with any questions. The stock in the store is vast. Family owned operated. I highly recommend Make A Cake for your specialty cake/pastry needs!

david-5378
07.08.2023

Helpful people. Lots of great merchandise.

mark-2454
07.08.2023

I drove an hour to reach the restaurant, knowing that I would arrive just before their closing time of 3pm. I called ahead to ask if they could wait a few extra minutes for me, but no one answered the phone and I had to leave a voicemail. When I arrived promptly at 3pm, the staff refused to open the door for me even though I assured them I knew what I wanted to order and had my credit card ready. They insisted that I come back when they reopen in two days. I was extremely disappointed by their lack of customer service and have no intention of returning to this restaurant in the future.

Menu

More information

QR-Code for the menu

QR-Code zur Speisekarte von Make A Cake

Suggested nearby restaurants.