Mary Cody's - Onalaska

#9 - Seafood - Onalaska, American, Italian

Mary Cody's

Mary Cody's
4.1 / 5 (647 reviews)

Description

Mary Cody's offers a mixed dining experience that sparks a range of opinions from patrons. While some appreciate the cozy atmosphere, friendly staff, and homemade breakfast options, others have encountered challenges such as long wait times, inconsistent service, and overcooked meals. The decor has been described as drab, with a disjointed menu failing to impress. However, instances of exceptional service, particularly during busy events like Mother's Day, highlight the staff's commitment to guest satisfaction. Overall, Mary Cody's embodies a charm that may appeal to some, but leaves others yearning for a more consistent and elevated dining experience.

Last update: 21.05.2026 from: Wyman

Feedback

★ 4.1 / 5 from 647 reviews
wyman56-1
12.06.2025

I think I enjoy the atmosphere more than anything. It?s just a decent little place to sit down and I?ve been here multiple times. Took my partner and mother-in-law here this time. My favorite time to stop in is definitely during breakfast. Theirprices could be better on certain things, but their food has yet to disappoint. Hope to visit again soon!!

cruickshank-martin
12.06.2025

Mary Cody and her catering staff were phenomenal. Not only was the food delicious, but it was presented and displayed in a deliciously inviting way. We had so many compliments from our guests on how wonderful the food was. Mary Cody met with usmultiple times to create a menu that was exactly what we were looking for, and that we were excited to share with our guests.She was also very conscientious of costs and made suggestions to help us save money where we could, while still ensuring greatquality.

zmurray-student0
12.06.2025

I literally had to stop eating to share this review today. I have been all over this planet, and this is the best breakfast and one of the best places to eat I have ever encountered! The food is at gourmet level flavor yet has that homemade appeal. Butwait, there's more! The atmosphere and epic-level friendly home style service is among the best I've ever encountered. Highlyrecommended for special occasions and cozy days. Just amazing!

maddie-b-chef92
03.05.2024

I recently started coming here and while I've only been here twice I would definitely give it a 4.5/5. The food was priced fairly especially because it was really good ! I've tried a few different items off the menu and have loved everything. The staff was very friendly which made the experience that much better. The small deduction was just for the wait for food but it was worth it !

sana-s-ivy6968
03.05.2024

Mary Cody 's reminds me of a restaurant you would see on Restaurant Impossible . The space itself is split into a bar at the entrance with a restaurant in the back, a family friendly layout I guess. However the decor is unbelievably drab. I can just imagine Robert Irvine walking in and removing all the ancient dusty Italian decor which he would refer to as the dust collectors . The ambiance overall is a bit dark and dreary. As far as food, nothing on the menu blew me away. Very Cheesecake Factory vibes or what Robert Irvine would refer to as an identity crisis . The menu seems to be a jack of all trades but a master of none. Also, the menu is categorized by poultry, beef/pork, seafood, etc., a bit odd. Service was meh, slow, nothing memorable. Very standard I suppose.

FAQ

The restaurant offers free WLAN for its visitors.

The joint offers the opportunity to view sporting events on a TV / screen.

You can also pay for your meals with various credit cards.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.