Buttersworths Bagels - Reviews (210)

Reviews

Overall Total Score

4.9 out of 5

Outstanding | 210 reviews

What Joyce S doesn't like about Buttersworths Bagels:
Sandwich I expected was a triple decker club this was two layers. . It wasn't terrible but I expected real Turkey breast not Turkey deli meat. I would Not order again. But the BAGELS from here are the BESTEST!! View all feedback.

Reviews from various websites

Linda

24.11.2023 - 18:13

Fresh cinnamon rasin bagel with honey walnut cream cheese was fantastic!

Joyce

24.11.2023 - 18:13

Sandwich I expected was a triple decker club this was two layers. . It wasn't terrible but I expected real Turkey breast not Turkey deli meat. I would Not order...

24.11.2023 - 18:13

First time customer. Ordered the Bobo. I was disappointed. Eggs were overcooked.

Donna

24.11.2023 - 18:13

Been coming to this place for years now and it NEVER disappoints.

Casey

24.11.2023 - 18:13

Delicious bagels and nice staff!

Last update : 24.11.2023

Contribute Feedback

Good Rated Restaurants near Old Tappan

Tortoise Hare

4.8

Menu

Table booking

4.8

Menu

Table booking

City: BRONX (near Old Tappan), 6115 Broadway, Bronx I-10471-3136, United States, BRONX

"Great place, awesome service awesome 10/10 recommend to everyone"

#Delivery Services

Delivery Services Casual Full Pubs

Smyrna Gyro

4.9

Menu

4.9

Menu

City: Wallington (near Old Tappan), 133 Main Ave, 07057, Wallington, US, United States

"It's a quaint little place, feels like I am being served by an auntie, and I loved it! Got the chicken gyro pita platter as well as their homemade bak..."

##4 Fast Food in Wallingto...

#4 Fast Food in Wallington

Bici

4.8

Menu

Table booking

4.8

Menu

Table booking

City: Ramsey (near Old Tappan), 61 East Main StreetNJ 07446, Ramsey, United States

"All around excellent. Popular for birthdays too!"

##24 Seafood in Ramsey

#24 Seafood in Ramsey Italian Dessert

Blue Hill At Stone Barns

4.8

Menu

Table booking

4.8

Menu

Table booking

City: Pocantico Hills (near Old Tappan), 630 Bedford Rd., Pocantico Hills, United States Of America, 10591

"Great experience, but something too expensive."

#American

American American Cuisine Coffee

Koi 21 Japanese Cuisine

4.8

Menu

Table booking

4.8

Menu

Table booking

City: Pearl River (near Old Tappan), 21 E Washington AveNY 109652313, Pearl River, United States

"Best sushi around. Exceptional service every time"

##4 Seafood in Pearl River

#4 Seafood in Pearl River Sushi

Sergio's

4.8

Menu

Table booking

4.8

Menu

Table booking

City: Pelham (near Old Tappan), 503 Fifth AveNY 10803, Pelham, United States

"Loved this little Italian restaurant, cozy and intimate"

#Italian

Italian Bar-lounge Full Ice Cream

BV Tuscany Italian

4.8

Menu

Table booking

4.8

Menu

Table booking

City: Teaneck (near Old Tappan), 368 Cedar LaneNJ 07666, 07666-3411, Teaneck, United States

"As always, the good was delicious and service was great"

Vegetarian Seafood Pizza Italian Full

Good Roots Natural Market

4.8

Menu

Table booking

4.8

Menu

Table booking

City: Haverstraw (near Old Tappan), 242 Rte 9W, Haverstraw, New York, USA, 10927, United States

"Food was delicious and the slushy was refreshing:"

Fast Food Pizza European Vegetarian

Peck Peck Chicken

4.8

Menu

Table booking

4.8

Menu

Table booking

City: Teaneck (near Old Tappan), 250 Degraw Ave, Teaneck I-07666-3206, United States

"Some of the best chicken I've ever had hands down"

#American

American Chicken Lunch Chicken Wings

Osaka Ryu Gin

4.8

Menu

Table booking

4.8

Menu

Table booking

City: Glen Rock (near Old Tappan), 1014 S Maple Ave, Glen Rock I-07452-2821, United States

"Great takeout food. It's always fresh and tasty."

##12 Seafood in Glen Rock

#12 Seafood in Glen Rock