Billy's - Old Forge

If you really appreciate Italian, Billy?s it is. Small and cozy on the main St in Old Forge, Billy?s could compete with the best of them! I usually calculate Italian from the sauce and meatballs, I have to say both were excellent! Other ducks, chicken parm, manicotti and vodka Riggies were also excellent. The atmosphere was like sitting on a Sunday at your mother-in-law, we loved it! Did?t really have high expectations for a tourist city, but Billy?s is the real deal! Reservations are a must, the dining area is small. Not even looking at the competition in the city, that's it!

Billy is the owner. He does it all with a smile on his face. Excellent food, staff and a mainstay in the local community. Usually very busy but make a reservation or order take out. Large portions of excellent Italian food. Prices are reasonable. You won't be disappointed!

Just had a great plate of spaghetti and meatballs. HUGE half roll of bread, plus a side salad. The other plates of food being served during my ridiculously short wait to get my food looked spectacular. This place is a hidden gem!

Billy's requires reservations, which were easily arranged by phone. We were seated promptly and were greeted by a delightful and attentive server who met all our requests. The food was delicious, as is always the case, and Billy's red marinara sauce is the best!

Our family loves Billy's, because you are treated like a member of the family as soon as you walk in. Bill greeted us and the servers were among the best we have encountered. We started with hot sausage stuffed cherry peppers which are to die for. The specials were prepared perfectly my wife had the chicken mushroom pesto alfredo, while I had the chicken and shrimp dijonnaise. Our son had his favorite, manicotti. We finished with fresh cannolis for dessert. We would not miss this favorite Old Forge eatery. Come for the delicious Italian specialties, stay for the excellent family atmosphere