Billy's - Old Forge

Billy's requires reservations, which were easily arranged by phone. We were seated promptly and were greeted by a delightful and attentive server who met all ou... read more Billy's requires reservations, which were easily arranged by phone. We were seated promptly and were greeted by a delightful and attentive server who met all our requests. The food was delicious, as is always the case, and Billy's red marinara sauce is the best!

Our family loves Billy's, because you are treated like a member of the family as soon as you walk in. Bill greeted us and the servers were among the best we hav... read more Our family loves Billy's, because you are treated like a member of the family as soon as you walk in. Bill greeted us and the servers were among the best we have encountered. We started with hot sausage stuffed cherry peppers which are to die for. The specials were prepared perfectly my wife had the chicken mushroom pesto alfredo, while I had the chicken and shrimp dijonnaise. Our son had his favorite, manicotti. We finished with fresh cannolis for dessert. We would not miss this favorite Old Forge eatery. Come for the delicious Italian specialties, stay for the excellent family atmosphere

De-lish-US!! and thanks to Billy, a local organization receives a part of the proceeds... fabulous food, great service last night.... so a great experience for... read more De-lish-US!! and thanks to Billy, a local organization receives a part of the proceeds... fabulous food, great service last night.... so a great experience for such a small space!

Billy went out of his way to cater a family memorial service for us. All of the food was absolutely delicious appetizers, pastas, chicken, eggplant and cannoli... read more Billy went out of his way to cater a family memorial service for us. All of the food was absolutely delicious appetizers, pastas, chicken, eggplant and cannoli (all of the Italian relatives loved it) and he delivered everything to the camp that wehad rented. I would highly recommend this restaurant!

Billy is the owner, and he manages everything with a smile. The food is exceptional, the staff is friendly, and the restaurant is a beloved staple in the local... read more Billy is the owner, and he manages everything with a smile. The food is exceptional, the staff is friendly, and the restaurant is a beloved staple in the local community. It tends to get quite busy, so it's a good idea to make a reservation or opt for takeout. The portions are generous, and the Italian cuisine is outstanding. The prices are also quite reasonable. You won't be disappointed!