Randy's - Old Forge

American, North American, Delivery Services

Randy's Restaurant in Old Forge, NY, is a charming American eatery that boasts a commendable average rating of 4.3 stars. Discover what diners have to say about their experiences at Randy's! If you're planning to visit and want to check the restaurant's current activity or make a reservation, feel free to call them at (315) 369-2888. Looking for a quick bite? Randy's has you covered! If you love the menu but wish to explore similar dining options, be sure to check out Benny's Ice Cream and Fastrac. Enjoyed your meal? We encourage you to leave a review!.

Last update: 11.12.2025 from: Shannon

Images

Contribute

Feedback

★ 4.3 / 5 from 361 reviews

Nestled in Old Forge, Randy’s offers a cozy, family-run dining experience with a menu full of comforting, homemade favorites like fried chicken, meatloaf, and fresh fish dinners. Known for friendly service, reasonable prices, and daily specials, the restaurant creates a warm atmosphere enhanced by thoughtful pandemic safety measures, including mask requirements and socially distanced seating. While some guests praise the personable owners and delicious meals, others advise calling ahead to secure a reservation, as walk-ins may face difficulties despite available tables. Overall, Randy’s stands out as a charming local gem delivering hearty meals and genuine hospitality.

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

I had a fantastic meal at a great price. The sauce they use is incredibly delicious!

Heather 17.02.2025 - 11:36

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

A delightful experience with comforting home-cooked food, excellent service, and a cozy atmosphere. Hats off to the chef and the server!

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

What a cozy, small place to get a homemade meal. I ordered the fried chicken, potatoes with Gravy and Koleslaw. It was wonderful! It came hot and fresh. The severity will knock you off your feet! My wife had an enormous BLT that was amazing! Reliable! The staff was quick and friendly. WOW! I can't say enough about Randy's! What a jewel in Old Forge!

Shannon 17.02.2025 - 11:36

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

The chicken is absolutely delicious! It was my 6-year-old's favorite meal during our time in Old Forge.

B 17.02.2025 - 11:36

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

This restaurant is extremely frustrating! I've never gotten the chance to eat here because, even when I show up early, I'm always turned away. This has happened to me three times now. I attempted to make a reservation, but they wouldn't accommodate me, despite there being an empty table. When I arrived less than five minutes after calling, I was turned away again. It's just not worth the hassle!

Feedback