Yesterdays Pub - Newark
Menu
The menu of Yesterdays Pub from Newark includes 53 courses. On average the courses or drinks on the menu cost approximately $7.8. You can view the categories on the menu below.
Nestled in Newark, this charming restaurant has garnered a loyal following for its inviting atmosphere, attentive staff, and delectable comfort food. Guests rave about the impressive decor, featuring vintage antiques and nostalgic touches. Signature dishes, such as perfectly seasoned liver and onions, hearty ham and bean soup, and outstanding crab cakes, leave diners eager for a return visit. While the occasional service hiccup can mar the experience, enthusiastic patrons find the restaurant's warmth and character irresistible. As they eagerly anticipate its seasonal reopening, many declare it a must-visit spot for food lovers seeking a taste of tradition and heartwarming ambiance.
Images
Feedback
Was User at Yesterdays Pub a mag?
This is the best small family restaurant in Newark! The staff was attentive, the decorations were impressive, and the food was absolutely delicious. I ordered the ham and bean soup with cornbread, and the beans were seasoned perfectly, packed with plenty of ham. For dessert, I had the bread pudding with cream sauce, which was simply amazing—just perfect. I learned that it was a recipe that's been passed down for 100... View all feedback.
What User dislikes about Yesterdays Pub:
We love and visit this place often, but only tried to go there and had the worst service! Immigrated and stood while two female employees just stared at us for about ten minutes. They finally decided to move motivated enough and tell us that it would wait a 45 minutes because they no longer have tables. Funny thing was on the front room there was another couple eating at a table and we are four tables in the same roo... View all feedback.
Stumbled upon this unassuming restaurant last week. Have eaten there twice since. Great food, friendly service nostalgic environment.What seems like just a little ranch house with white siding is a cover for the blast back in time once you enter the front door. Impressive, massive, beautiful antique bar greets you. Vintage antique kitschy decor scattered on the walls and bar kept me entertained just looking at every nook and cranny. The dining room with bentwood chairs with red white checkered tablecloths remind me of the original Buddy ‘s Pizza in Detroit.Now on to the food- The awesome burger truly is awesome. Cooked perfectly and full of toppings. We were fortunate enough to get the last order of crab cakes they did not disappoint! HUGE chunks of crab absolutely delicious. Rueben sandwich had shaved corned beef vs giant thick slices which I loved. Homemade Clam chowder is the best I’ve ever had. You can taste the love it’s made with I bet it’s a 100 year old recipe it’s that good. Can’t wait to go back and try the French onion soup everyone raves about.
Stumbled upon this unassuming restaurant last week. Have eaten there twice since. Great food, friendly service nostalgic environment.What seems like just a little ranch house with white siding is a cover for the blast back in time once you enter the front door. Impressive, massive, beautiful antique bar greets you. Vintage antique kitschy decor scattered on the walls and bar kept me entertained just looking at every nook and cranny. The dining room with bentwood chairs with red white checkered tablecloths remind me of the original Buddy ‘s Pizza in Detroit.Now on to the food- The awesome burger truly is awesome. Cooked perfectly and full of toppings. We were fortunate enough to get the last order of crab cakes they did not disappoint! HUGE chunks of crab absolutely delicious. Rueben sandwich had shaved corned beef vs giant thick slices which I loved. Homemade Clam chowder is the best I’ve ever had. You can taste the love it’s made with I bet it’s a 100 year old recipe it’s that good. Can’t wait to go back and try the French onion soup everyone raves about.
Amazing homemade food! Great eclectic little joint that anyone looking for a unique place should go.
Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5
Full Menu
Gourmet Sandwich
Philly Chicken Breast Fillet$7.9 Haddock Fishtail$6.9Children'S Menu
Kids Pub Dog$2.9M'Mi M'Mi Good Soup
Bowl Of Ham And Bean Soup$4.9Salads
This Old House Salad$3.9Soups
New England Clam Chowder (Available Most Weekends)$7.0
More information
QR-code link to the menu
This restaurant offers
Suggested nearby restaurants.
★ 4.8 / 5 (1599 reviews)American Breakfast DinersBig Apple Cafe
1283 Log Pond Dr, Newark, OH, 43055, United States
"Excellent service and the best breakfast I have had in a long time. Thank you!!Food: 5/5"
★ 4.8 / 5 (1107 reviews)Sandwiches Grill Cheese Meat TakeawayBaba's Grill
East Main Street 112, 43055 Newark, US
"We always try new places to eat and this place was of the charts! It is a must try for anyone looking for some great food. I am sorry we didnt try it..."
★ 5.0 / 5 (1084 reviews)Pizza Cheese TakeawayPlaza Pizza Newark Oh
1130 Mount Vernon Rd, 1, Newark, Ohio, USA, 43055, United States
"Since my last visit in April 2025, I've noticed a significant change in the pizzas I ordered a couple of nights ago. Unfortunately, it's not for the b..."