Reviews
What Ellen Treuer doesn't like about Sugar Sweet Sunshine Bakery:
One of my favorite cupcake shops. Got their regular sunshine cupcake. The base isn't as sweet as other cupcakes but the frosting didn't have much taste. Their lemon and strawberry pudding with whipped cream was delicious. It was light, had chunks of strawberries and not too sweet. View all feedback. What A Z likes about Sugar Sweet Sunshine Bakery:
The banana pudding here is absolutely DIVINE! I've only tried the original and the red velvet so far but they're both absolutely delicious! The original is quite similar to Magnolia's famous banana pudding, so not much else to be said about that! The red velvet, however, is truly unexpected as I thought the red velvet would have completely overpowered the banana. Thankfully, the flavors actually complemented each oth... View all feedback.
Reviews from various websites
The banana pudding here is a must try. hands down the best banana pudding in nyc (might be a hot take but i don’t think so! i thoroughly enjoyed all the other p...
read moreI come here for the puddings. The puddings are the absolute best in NYC. Blows Magnolias out of the water. They have different flavors on the menu and they are...
read moreGreat place to get amazing treats for the best prices. I definitely will be going back on my cheat days !!
I get my black and white just right cupcake from SSS every birthday since I was 5 years old. And I’ll be 22 at the end of this month lol. They are my favorite!!...
read moreOne of my favorite cupcake shops. Got their regular sunshine cupcake. The base isn't as sweet as other cupcakes but the frosting didn't have much taste. Their l...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreWe tried strawberry trifle and Oreo cupcakes. Strawberry trifle is recommended, it is light and nice to eat. It is closer to Eton mess rather than a trifle. We...
read moreI was excited to try the cupcakes at this bakery after seeing all the great reviews but found them pretty underwhelming. My friends and I shared a pistachio, le...
read moreWe had Deb the team create a fantastic 1970s disco-themed cake for our birthday, along with a sheet cake to serve to our guests. Deb was extremely helpful with...
read moreMy answer to the owner: it was a different flavor, don't know which ingredient was different or maybe was changed the brand of the ingredients, don't know...My...
read moreCupcakes were absolutely delicious. Stopped by on a random Tuesday at 7pm. Cupcakes were light and airy but still sweet and moist. Sweet but not too sweet, and...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreI had two teasers of pudding (banana, and didn't catch the name of the second, but it had butterscotch). Both good. Also a blue cupcake, nice and soft the base...
read moreSugar Sweet Sunshine is a small bakery on Rivington Street. a small space is dominated with displays of the various a sweet treats. there are a several small ta...
read moreThe cupcakes are good but oh my gosh the pudding, the Chocolate Bomb is FANTASTIC. The banana pudding is yummy as well but the Chocolate Bomb is out of this wor...
read moreGreat selection of 8+ pudding flavors. The classic banana was great, but the java was a surprising favorite reminded me of tiramisu. Love that there are multipl...
read moreFirst time trying this place and DEFINITELY wont be my last. This place is GAS. I got the banana pudding, chocolate chip pudding, vanilla cupcake, and strawberr...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreOur favorite desert strawberry lemon trifle pudding. We love it.
Slice of coconut cream and red velvet cupcake was destroyed
Banana pudding and Chocolate Chip Deliciousness are so so good! Not to mention the cupcakes!
They send their own drivers so whatever time it says for delivery double it, at least
Bread pudding is so good
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreAlways fresh cupcakes, tons of flavors, and their puddings are great too. I've ordered from the Essex Market and the location on Rivington.
Try the strawberry lemon trifle or the chocolate chip cookie pudding! So yummy. I also ordered the pistachio cupcake which was very light and natural...
The bread pudding here is so good! My favorite was the chocolate one since I'm a chocolate lover. We also had the banana one and a strawberry shortcake kind...
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read more