San Matteo Pizzeria e Cucina - Feedback

A jewel on the upper east side. amazing burger and service. I can not wait to return and try her dry aged tomahawk, pizza and tasty looking pasta.

Always delicious! loves the Arugula salad, all and all pizzas and the auberginen parmigiana appetizer. I also recommend their award-winning burger.

Just back from Naples (world’s best pizza! and we were trying to re-create that dining experience. San Mateo came very close!! So good!

One of the better (as in more authentic Neapolitan pizza places in the city

San Matteo was fantastic! Delicious food and great service! I had the penne con melanzane and my husband had Cotto e bufala pizza. The arancini appetizer was a...

The service was excellent. Some of us in our group enjoyed the pizza while others tried items from the rest of the menu. Everything was fantastic.

I had a great experience at this restaurant. The waitress, Carmela, was fantastic. Even though I live in New Jersey, I would definitely return when I am in the...

Fantastic dinner. Great for our whole family. This has become a must when we are on the Upper East Side.

The pizza and service were excellent, and the atmosphere was very pleasant.

Some of the best Italian food on the UES. Fantastic selection of food as well as great range of flavor. Incredibly tasty and hearty dishes.

Review of San Matteo Pizzeria e Cucina I recently had the pleasure of dining at San Matteo Pizzeria e Cucina, and it was an experience that truly captured the...

Great real Italian pizza in NY! I can even tell one of the best in the city.

Exactly what we wanted out of a neighborhood Italian place.

The « Tartufata » was the best pizza I’ve had in a long time. Perfect balance between the ingredients, not too salty, the ham was very thin and the truffle tast...

Pretty decent neopolitan style pizza as opposed to NY slices. We get this a decent amount since it's on the way home. The only knock is that I do feel like thei...

The pizza i got was extremly salty and fell apart right when i picked up a slice. The crust was so thin that it could have been non-exsitent, and even after add...

Ordered the burger and a pizza. The food didn't taste fresh and the flavouring was off.

Excellent pie and salad. These people are serious and you won't go wrong here.

Delicious pizza, my only go-to for pizza as a born and raised Italian!

Great pizza melanzane e arancini

Love the servers here, super friendly and informative. Ordered a pizza and two pasta dishes everything was flavorful and presented well. Had an amazing truffle...

We went there on a Saturday evening. Very nice staff, delicious pizzas ! A family place obviously, which was nice. The tiramisu is homemade, no doubt, and reall...

Nice place, but pizza quality could be improved. It is funny that the waiters pretend to be Italian by saying stereotypical things (mamma Mia! Signore! LOL). Ma...

Ordered two margheritas through postmates. Top photo is the regular magherita and the bottom is the Regina magherita. Tasted like normal thin crust pizza. I exp...

I tried 2 pizzas, de Luca, prosciutto and mozzarella and tiramisù espresso. The pizza dough was good, light and soft. Ingredients were fresh and flavorful. Abou...