Reviews
What Drew Jacob doesn't like about Old Post Office Bagel Shop:
Decent food and friendly staff, but the proprietor, Bill, enjoys being rude and confrontational with his customers. There are better breakfast options across the street at the Cracked Mug or around the corner at Persephone's. View all feedback. What Nathan likes about Old Post Office Bagel Shop:
The best bagels I've ever eaten, they are second to none in my opinion. Great selection and everything is made fresh. I can't say enough good things about this place. View all feedback.
Reviews from various websites
Stopped at this bagel shop around 11am. It was pretty packed but the line moves fairly quickly. They were only open from 6:30 to noon so I was happy we were abl...
read moreWhenever I 'm in block island, I will always make this my spot for breakfast. I found them my first day here on this trip and was incredibly impressed. I love t...
read moreIf you are looking for the best bagels outside of NYC, this is the place. Each time I’ve been to block island I have stopped here before the ferry to get bagels...
read moreIt was a good bagel. Seating was ok, portion was good and it just hit the spot. Worth a stop if you're on Block Island.
I really enjoyed my bagel with cream cheese, muffin, and iced chai. The prices are good, especially since everything on the island is more expensive. Enjoyed ea...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreBLT breakfast sandwich on an everything bagel with avocado!!
Always great, fresh breakfast foods and coffee!! Very convenient location as well!
The best bagels I've ever eaten, they are second to none in my opinion. Great selection and everything is made fresh. I can't say enough good things about this...
read moreWhen I went there, there were 6 types of bagels. They have different types of cream cheese available and they have drinks available from a cooler fridge. I woul...
read moreSuper busy. Line out the door but moves quickly. Good sized portions.
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreBest bagel I think I've ever had and I'm from NY. Not to mention their incredible, one of a kind, giant muffins and scones. Everything is homemade and fresh. Fa...
read moreIf your on Block Island, or plan to visit; you have to stop in at the Post Office Bagel shop. Delicious, perfectly baked, crispy outside, chewy inside bagels. W...
read moreThe burrito was delish. The staff does a great job moving the people along. It's busy but they get you served quickly. Terrific!!
Decent food and friendly staff, but the proprietor, Bill, enjoys being rude and confrontational with his customers. There are better breakfast options across th...
read moreHave had their bagels for years , and it must be the water. They are dense, almost to dense. But good. Its just weird.
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read more