Pace's Dockside - Mattituck

#21 - Pizza - Mattituck, American, Steak
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.
Reservation
Reservation request for Pace's Dockside.

Pace's Dockside

Pace's Dockside
4.0 / 5 (1237 reviews)

Menu

A complete menu of Pace's Dockside from Mattituck featuring all 79 meals and drinks can be found here on the menu.

Pace's Dockside Restaurant offers a delicious selection of American food in Mattituck. Join us to savor our scrumptious menu items like noodles. Call us at (631) 315 5252 to reserve a table today! Visit us to create unforgettable memories and amazing culinary experiences.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Mariam

Images

Pace's Dockside Food Pace's Dockside Food Pace's Dockside Drink Pace's Dockside Outside Pace's Dockside Menu Pace's Dockside Drink Pace's Dockside Outside Pace's Dockside Food

Reservation request for Pace's Dockside

Enquire Reservation Now

Feedback

★ 4 / 5 from 1237 reviews

The restaurant in question has received mixed reviews from customers. Some have complained about poor service, seating next to a loud and distracting area, long wait times, and subpar food quality. While others have praised it for its delicious food, friendly and attentive staff, beautiful atmosphere with outdoor dining options, and enjoyable live music. It seems like the overall experience at the restaurant can be hit or miss, with some diners vowing to never return while others plan on coming back. Despite the mixed feedback, Pampano's Dockside seems to have a loyal following with those who enjoy its creative Mexican seafood dishes and inviting atmosphere.

mia56
12.04.2022

The food was disgusting really not edible. We waited mins for a pizza and two sandwiches which tasted like they were frozen and warmed in a microwave. DO NOT GO TO THIS RESTAURANT

pweimann
12.04.2022

Went out with a group of women as a mom's night out. Great view of the inlet and sunset. The live music was good. The bar waa lively and a great place to stay after dinner for some drinks. The specialty cocktail menu was worth the money. The food selection was extensive and maybe a bit overwhelming. The service was good. Dessert was the only disappointment as two of the choices were not very tasty. Overall a great place to dine.

gweissnat-office276
12.04.2022

Had a wonderful few days on our boat at strongs marina which is on the same grounds of Paces. Great asset to have such a great bar and restaurant at a marina. We will be back

mariam
29.08.2024

Everything else was great, but I was disappointed by the beet salad. The beets tasted canned, which was a letdown. Serving canned beets and charging as if they were fresh isn’t acceptable.

davidl
29.08.2024

I had a disappointing experience at Pace's Dockside. When I arrived, they claimed I didn't have a reservation, despite me showing my confirmation on OpenTable. They said they were no longer affiliated with the service, which forced me to rebook for a different time. Once there, we were seated in a very dim back room, even though there were many open tables in the front. When I asked the hostess why, she replied that she was told to alternate seating between the front and back rooms, and when I inquired about waiting for a front room table, her response was quite rude, stating that no one had ever asked her that before. Eventually, they moved us to the front, but we were placed directly in front of the door at what felt like the worst table in the house, despite several other open options. The food was decent, and the drinks were acceptable, but overpriced for this part of Long Island. We faced an extremely long wait between appetizers and main courses, and no one checked on us for bread or water. The system seemed disorganized, as we encountered three separate mistakes with our orders: sweet potato mash instead of regular, raw clams instead of clams casino, and regular wings instead of duck wings. To top it off, my wife’s vegetables were forgotten and only arrived after we prompted the waiter at the end of the meal. You would think they might offer a glass of wine, take something off the bill, or at least apologize for the mishaps, but none of that happened. Overall, it was a frustrating dining experience.

  • Salads

    Pace's Caesar Salad
    Pace's Caesar Salad
  • Burger

    Pace's Burger
    Pace's Burger
  • Entrées

    Pace's Filet Sliders
    Pace's Filet Sliders
    Steak House Potato Skins
    Steak House Potato Skins
  • Charboiled Steaks

    New York Shell Steak (Marinated Or Plain)
    New York Shell Steak (Marinated Or Plain)
    Porterhouse For One (Marinated Or Plain)
    Porterhouse For One (Marinated Or Plain)

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.