East On Main - Mattituck

Just a nice place to dine with great food, I like the seafood! Ambiance is also great and its a comfortable place to hold your seasonal parties. Try it, the staff is personable too!

We had a party for about 50 people. Stephanie, Tony, and their team made a meaningful party special for all who attended. Their communication throughout the planning was always very clear and timely. We arrived to a warm welcome and were taken care of from start to finish by a professional, caring, and fun team. We didn’t hear any complaints from the guests, only joy and gratitude. The East on Main team made it so there were no concerns, only a good time with delicious food and drinks.I recommend this place for not only dinner but to hold an event. I look forward to the next party at East on Main.

Don't let the photo of the chicken pot pie on this site fool you, I was served a tepid bowl of grey tasteless chicken mush with a tough piece of some kind of pastry on top that my butter knife could not cut. . Another guest in my party was server the same. This place is gritty, outdated, and WAY overrated. I am confused by it's 4 star rating which led me there. Gordon Ramsey could do a full season trying to fix this place. I will say the front of the house was pleasant, with friendly service.

Service was good. Food was bland. We won’t be back.

As locals, we've been meaning to try East on Main for quite some time. It's been a very busy summer and we haven't had a chance until this Friday night and we decided to try the new venue. In spite of a bridal rehearsal dinner party in the back room and a large table for eight people we had excellent service from our waitress Samantha. We started our meal with the mussels in a white wine garlic sauce that we enjoyed. Hubby decided on the honey crisp fried chicken special , it was served with a corn bread stuffing, and a side fresh string beans, the chicken was crispy, moist and extremely good. I ordered the shrimp and scallops with mushrooms, tomato and a white wine sauce, it was served piping hot and very flavorful. At the end of the meal we were very satisfied and knew we would be coming back. We are happy to find a new local place that offers fresh food and a casual but lovely atmosphere. Thank you Samantha, thank you East on Main!.