Windamere - Mattituck

The restaurant experience was far from satisfactory, as the management was unprepared for the holiday rush. Despite the beautiful surroundings and potential, th... read more The restaurant experience was far from satisfactory, as the management was unprepared for the holiday rush. Despite the beautiful surroundings and potential, the understaffed restaurant led to a bad experience. The humble staff seemed eager to improve, but were limited. It is recommended to check your bill carefully as we were overcharged, but the situation was rectified with an appropriate discount considering the disastrous night.

The waterfront setting was beautiful, however, the food was mediocre. The fish and chips as well as the burger were both too salty and overcooked. read more The waterfront setting was beautiful, however, the food was mediocre. The fish and chips as well as the burger were both too salty and overcooked.

Delicious food exceptional service and wonderful atmosphere. I highly recommend Windermere especially if you're staying at Strong's Water Club Mattituck. read more Delicious food exceptional service and wonderful atmosphere. I highly recommend Windermere especially if you're staying at Strong's Water Club Mattituck.

Nice place, friendly service, live music. There are the 3 stars. Food was just ok. Hit or miss. The menu is very small. Party of 4…. The lobster Cobb was great... read more Nice place, friendly service, live music. There are the 3 stars. Food was just ok. Hit or miss. The menu is very small. Party of 4…. The lobster Cobb was great but small. The shrimp scampi was good but I thought it had way too much garlicand lemon. The burger and truffle fries were great. The skirt steak was horrible. They use the strangest dry rub seasoningI’ve ever tasted. Forget that it was raw when it was served, the taste was like burnt hair. I kid you not. You need a newchef. Anyone who puts out food like that without tasting it first is in the wrong business. This place is not worth the highprices. Will not be back.

DINNER MUST COME WITH PEPTOBISMOL Not a coincidence that 3ppl who went there and have diarrhea. While eating my husband texted me saying don’t get seafood from... read more DINNER MUST COME WITH PEPTOBISMOL Not a coincidence that 3ppl who went there and have diarrhea. While eating my husband texted me saying don’t get seafood from there because he thinks he caught a bad stomach virus from there last time he ate there. Ourlunch was awful. FOOD IS NOT FRESH !!!! Wonder how clean the chef is. My sister-in-law got a chicken sandwich with batter thattasted like seafood. The 3 of us have a stomach ache and it’s not fun. Not going there again.