Reviews
What Sage Myers likes about Buttercooky Bakery:
I absolutely love this place!! My grandparents used to live in Floral Park, and I can't believe my mom never took us there before! I decided to stop in at the MANHASSET location today on a whim, just wanting some good coffee, but ended up being blown away by how amazing and well-made everything looked. The staff was very friendly and attentive, despite being quite busy for a mid-week early evening. Not many bakeries... View all feedback. What Vito P doesn't like about Buttercooky Bakery:
If you want a surprise for your wedding cake , this is the bakery to order from! We specifically stated what flavors we wanted for the filling, and the color of the decorative flowers on the cake. Both were COMPLETELY WRONG, and we reached out multiple times with NO REPLY. Thank god the wedding was memorable because the Cake surely wasn?t. Very disappointed in you guys for getting both the inside and outside of cake... View all feedback.
Reviews from various websites
I absolutely love this place!! My grandparents used to live in Floral Park, and I can't believe my mom never took us there before! I decided to stop in at the M...
read moreI visited this restaurant for the first time last week, although I usually frequent the one in Floral Park. I was very impressed with the seating area and the m...
read moreI recently picked up my mom's birthday cake and it was absolutely exceptional! It exceeded all of my expectations and I am extremely grateful. Eric was incredib...
read moreI normally patronize Jericho Turnpike. I found this location by accident and I was not disappointed. TEN STARS
<3 Love <3 the Pignoli Cookies (my favorites) and Epsresso... nothing better!
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreThis restaurant is a must-visit for me since I am in the area once or twice a month. They offer a wide variety of high-quality options and have a dedicated staf...
read moreIf you want a surprise for your wedding cake , this is the bakery to order from! We specifically stated what flavors we wanted for the filling, and the color of...
read moreThere are so many delicious options at this restaurant, including the Red velvet croissant, cakes, and Cheese Danish. The assortment of cakes is extensive, and...
read moreToday, I visited the Manhasset location for brunch with a friend. When we arrived at the bakery, there were hardly any other customers present. Unfortunately, w...
read moreMay have had one of the best cookies ever! (But I?m a huge fan of white chocolate). Delicious pastries
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreI absolutely love all of the desserts at this restaurant. My favorite treats are the Smore's Cream Puff, Nutella Caramel Eclair, and the Pistachio Cherry cake -...
read moreI absolutely adore this restaurant! They create incredible holiday cakes with fondant and everything! Their delivery service is incredibly fast, their customer...
read moreThis bakery serves the most delicious pastries and provides excellent service! I highly recommend it!
Delicious the Fresh Fruit Tart , the Tres Leche Bowl, Raspberry Macaron and NY Cheesecake pastry
Great breakfast pastries alway fresh tasty
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreThe bakery is delicious but a bit pricey. I bought a babka/bobka (not sure how to spell it) for my father-in-law and it was amazing. It was perfectly moist and...
read moreI stopped by Buttercooky in Manhasset for a last-minute dessert on a rainy Saturday night. It was pouring rain outside, so the restaurant was empty when I arriv...
read moreI am aware that my favorite bakery has a branch in Manhasset to this day. The location is conveniently near my new optometrist's office, making it easily access...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read more