Jericho Cider Mill - Menu

I stopped by on July 4th to pick up a pie. Last year, I had a wonderful Key Lime Pie, but unfortunately, they didn't have it this time, so I opted for a classic... read more I stopped by on July 4th to pick up a pie. Last year, I had a wonderful Key Lime Pie, but unfortunately, they didn't have it this time, so I opted for a classic Blueberry pie. How could you go wrong with that? Well, at $28.09 for a standard-sized pie, I was disappointed. After one slice, the rest ended up in the garage. It seems like this place has lost its edge. Honestly, a store-bought pie at a third of the price would have been a better choice.

The pricing here is outrageous, and the gallon of cider I purchased tasted more like dirty water than anything enjoyable. It seems this place has become complac... read more The pricing here is outrageous, and the gallon of cider I purchased tasted more like dirty water than anything enjoyable. It seems this place has become complacent with its products, and the quality has seriously declined. Charging $12 for half a dozen cider donuts is excessive, especially when the $9 gallon of cider tasted so terrible that I ended up throwing it away. In contrast, I got a gallon of cider from a different orchard while I was upstate for only $6, and the donuts there were just a dollar each. That cider was sweet and flavorful, unlike the unpleasant, earthy taste of the cider from Jericho Cider Mill. It's disheartening to see this once-great spot turn into a clear money grab with subpar offerings.