Simeon's American Bistro - Ithaca

Seafood, Mexican, Sushi
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.
Reservation
Reservation request for Simeon's American Bistro.

Simeon's American Bistro

Simeon's American Bistro
4.2 / 5 (581 reviews)

Description

Simeon's restaurant in Ithaca Commons has received mixed reviews from patrons. The recent redecorating was well done, but some found the food to be tasty yet a bit overpriced for the portion sizes. While the kale salad, salmon, and steak were all noted as delicious choices, some diners were left disappointed by slow service and loud atmosphere during their visits. In contrast, others had a positive experience with excellent food, friendly service, and a welcoming atmosphere. The restaurant offers a variety of locally sourced dishes and a good wine selection, making it a nice spot for a special occasion or date night. Despite some inconsistencies in service and quality, Simeon's remains a popular dining option in the heart of downtown Ithaca.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Kimberly

Reservation request for Simeon's American Bistro

Submit Reservation Request

Feedback

★ 4.2 / 5 from 581 reviews
kimberly-quesada
01.10.2024

Great service, beautiful place and amazing food! My favorite place for brunch, really recommended.

sanaz-sadeghi-firefi
01.10.2024

This is a famous place in Ithaca, however, some of their dishes might not live up to expectation. So you really have to either try and see which ones you like, or do some research before and see what they are famous for. Here are the ones that I liked for brunch: espresso martini, French toast, Croque Madame. I do not recommend their omelettes in general.

jane-dunn-3
01.10.2024

My husband and I were here tonight for our date night. We were delighted! The watermelon feta salad was bright and tasty. My husband had mussels which he was craving; he loved them! I had the sea bass special; absolutely delicious! I had the pinot grigio; wonderful! Taylor was very attentive and professional. Thank you! We will return! ??

j-p-elephant5428
01.10.2024

The food was excellent, although the fries could use some improvement. The staff was fantastic. I would definitely recommend this place.

michael-pawloski-1
01.10.2024

This place is my favorite place to go for date night. The bartender is amazing and the food is to die for. The colors and decor is perfect. I talk about this place to all my friends and family. Everytime I go here I look forward to the next time I come back lol. Just awesome

FAQ

A little farther located is Green Street Station, where you can also access the public transportation.

You can use the WiFi of the establishment free of charge.

You can also pay for your meals with the common credit cards.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.