College Town Pizza - Ithaca

#10 - Pizza - Ithaca, #20 - Mexican - Ithaca, Casual
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

College Town Pizza

College Town Pizza
3.5 / 5 (257 reviews)

Description

Nestled in the heart of Ithaca, this restaurant offers a diverse menu that strikes a chord with locals. Diners rave about the gyro over rice, touted as the best in the area, alongside consistently tasty pizzas that, while slightly pricier, are regarded as a top choice. The eggplant parmesan sub paired with fries has also garnered praise. Many have enjoyed the welcoming atmosphere, complemented by a friendly owner who remembers regulars, making it a favored spot for casual meals. While there have been some concerns over food freshness, the overall experience keeps patrons returning for more delicious offerings.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Nakia

Feedback

★ 3.5 / 5 from 257 reviews
gust60
31.07.2022

The spicy chicken wrap and the hüi offerings at this restaurant are absolutely delicious. The owner is very welcoming, making this establishment highly recommended.

kathleen-glover
31.07.2022

I ordered a large cheese pizza with a delicious thin crust. I requested it for 6 o'clock, arrived a few minutes early, and the owner had it ready right on time at 6!

peyton-heaney
31.07.2022

The pizzas at this restaurant are consistently good, although they are a bit higher priced. However, they are considered one of the better options for pizza in Ithaca. Additionally, the location is convenient and lovely.

padberg-nakia
18.04.2023

The Spicy Chicken Wrap and chicken dishes are absolutely delicious. The owner is very welcoming, making the experience even better. I highly recommend this restaurant!

hahn-billie
18.04.2023

I ordered a large cheese pizza with a thin crust, and it tasted fantastic! I called ahead for a 6:00 pickup, arrived a few minutes early, and the owner had it perfectly ready right on time!

FAQ

A little farther located is Green Street Station, where you can also access the public transportation.

There is a TV / screen on-site where sporting events are shown.

The rooms on site are wheelchair accessible and can also be used with a wheelchair or physical limitations.

The place also accepts credit cards from the common providers as a means of payment.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.