Reviews - Amore Italian
Reviews summary
Amore, an Italian restaurant in Indiana, has elicited diverse reactions from diners. While some guests rave about the exceptional quality of the homemade dishes and attentive service, celebrating special occasions and returning for more, others express stark disappointment, particularly with the lasagna and chicken francese, which they found unappetizing. Although the restaurant occasionally experiences service hiccups, patrons appreciate the generous portions and flavorful pasta options. Despite some unfavorable comparisons to more established establishments, many appreciate Amore's charm, seeing it as a worthwhile dining destination that beautifully captures the essence of Italian cuisine.
Was Anonym at Amore Italian a mag?
This was our first visit. We had a very early dinner. Service was good, food was excellent. Server was very attentive. We really enjoyed the stuffed mushroom caps. They were very very good. View all feedback.
What Антонина Борисов dislikes about Amore Italian:
I was excited to see an Italian restaurant on the Indiana side. Was disappointed to find out this is the worst Italian food I've ever had. I had Lasagna, it was like it was baked dry without sauce, then a Vodka sauce poured around it before serving. Just terrible. Wife had Chicken Francese, did not resemble any I've ever seen before and the flavor was tasteless. Can't figure out how this place was rated as high as Vo... View all feedback.
Reviews from various users
Last update : 07.04.2026
Food is Fabulous and the service was exceptional! Love this restaurant
Two of the 4 dinners were just warm, not hot
This was our first visit. We had a very early dinner. Service was good, food was excellent. Server was very attentive. We really enjoyed the stuffed mushroom caps. They were very very good.
Great food and service
Last update : 11.05.2023
My wife and I just had our first meal here. I usually eat half a meal and take the other half home. It was so good, I ate everything before I could stop. I'm so full. Our waiter Chris was excellent, along with all the staff. I recommend this restaurant. The only negative was the music a little loud, and not the right genre for an Italian restaurant, but the food and service made more than for them.
Great anniversary dinner tonight with my hubby!! Al hit a home run with the entree’s; and Chris was a fabulous server who happens to make killer desserts!!! Highlight: The Caesar salad was by far the best I’ve ever had. And the Bourbon sour apple caramel blended drink #wow We will be back!!!!! Wonderful service!
I can't say good enough here. No matter what I had or how I asked, it's the best of all time. I'm on a special diet, but don't let you get away from here. You will be pretty much everything you ask, and not even lose a little taste. Bravo Amore's!
Eat here for the first time. It was great. I had the five cheese lobster Mac and cheese it was to die for tasty my husband had aubergines parmesan and he absolutely loved it, we will be back and bring some of our family (Kids and grandchild) we loved the atmosphere a beautiful place. The owner visited all guests. He was kids. The boss is the best. This place is open for 5 months. We didn't even know until our Wednesday mail, it had coupons. The line here was at the door. It was great.
So glad we found this place! We had dinner on 10/5/17 and it was one of the best Italian meals I have ever had and that is saying a lot considering I come from a family of Italian immigrants! I had one of the nightly specials, the beef medallions with asparagus and garlic mashed potatoes. Every bite was so good I never wanted it to end! My husband had a veal dish and loved it just as much. Kudos to Chef Al on fine Italian dining done right! We will definitely be back!
