Reviews - Pie Goddess
Reviews summary
The Pie Goddess in Enumclaw garners mixed reviews, reflecting a fluctuating quality and charm. Longtime fans reminisce about unforgettable flavors, such as the butterscotch lush and blackberry pie, while some recent patrons lament the disappointing crusts and lackluster fillings, like the overly salty beef curry pie and bland chocolate cream. Despite its dedicated following, new ownership may have impacted consistency. Still, many believe the bakery's savory and dessert offerings, including chicken pot pie and various fruity delights, are worth the journey. Visitors are encouraged to try for themselves, as opinions vary widely on this beloved pie shop.
Reviews from various users
Last update : 18.04.2025
Disappointed. Tried the Black Forest, chocolate cream, and blueberry. Unevenly cooked and disproportionate Krusteaz pie crust, jello pudding filling, and cool whip topping do not equate to a $6 slice of pie. Save yourself the time, money anddisappointment and go anywhere else.
For $6 youd be better off with a handful of store bought hand pies like the ones in the photo. We got a slice of blueberry, chocolate creme, and black forest. The black forest was ok and the others werent much to write home about.... so im writing mythoughts here. They use Krusteaz brand pie crust--they dont even make it from scratch! And it is flat and bland and not flakyat all. Ive actually had store-bought pie better than these
I tried the banana cream pie. I took one bite and immediately spit it out, no idea what it was but I definitely didn't taste anything sweet. Texture was gross, not like any banana cream pie I've had before. Unfortunately disappointing :
THE place for fresh and delicious pies! We've had the Shepherds pies, berry pies, and specialty pies with no regrets. Less budget friendly than supermarket bakery pies but not even in the same category for comparison. You get what you pay for here.
The best savory and sweet pies in Enumclaw area. We got the Shepherds pie and some dessert pies and wer super sumptuos.
Last update : 01.03.2025
Honestly, the worst pie I’ve ever had. I’ve had better storebought pies from the frozen food aisle. It tasted like it was days old. The texture of the pie was weird. The crust was completely flavorless and had a very unappetizing texture (soggy, stale). The whipped cream on top had a very old taste and texture to it. I immediately threw it into the trash after two bites. We are so disappointed we wasted our money. Service: Takeaway Food: 1 Service: 1 Atmosphere: 1
We heard about this place through friends and have always wanted to try it. It’s a little bit pricy, but worth it for special occasions. We bought a sweet pie Pumpkin Lush, and a savory pie Curry Beef Pot Pie. They were both outstanding! The Curry Beef is my new favorite savory pie. Service: Takeaway Meal type: Other Price per person: $30–50 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 4 Parking space: Somewhat difficult to find parking Parking options: Free of charge parking lot, Free of charge street parking
I first went here in 2013 and experienced a “pie-gasm” as the original owner put it. I’ve never lived near here, but I’ve made it a point to stop by at least twice a year for my favorite pie: butterscotch lush. The original owner passed away during the covid years, sadly, the pie was just as delicious the last time I visited. Service: Takeaway Meal type: Other Price per person: $20–30 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 3 Recommended dishes: Butterscotch Lush Parking space: Plenty of parking Parking options: Free of charge parking lot
Both slices of pie I bought have an old and stale consistency to them as if they’d been sitting over a week. Taste isn’t great, but isn’t terrible; both have an okay flavor at best. I have heard mixed reviews from locals. Some good and some bad. I am on the side of bad after trying 2 slices. I bought lemon and chocolate pie. I will not be back. Service: Takeaway Price per person: $10–20 Food: 1 Service: 2 Atmosphere: 2
We were in town and went here because it had good reviews. I'm not sure if it's under new ownership, but our meal was not worth finishing. We each had the beef curry pie. It was incredibly salty, the crust was soft, soggy, and flavorless, and the center was ice cold. I also had the chocolate cream pie, which was described to me as being rich and chocolatey. It tasted more like unflavored whipped topping. I would not go again, and frankly regret going once. Service: Takeaway Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $10–20 Food: 1 Service: 2 Atmosphere: 2
Last update : 06.11.2023
The quality has truly declined; the pies appeared barely baked with a pale, doughy crust. It's such a disappointment to witness this local gem deteriorate so much.
They didn't have a Coconut Cream Pie available, which is my favorite for my birthday, but they made one for me while we waited. It was excellent—thank you so much!
Last update : 03.05.2023
This is hands down the best cherry cake I've ever had!!! I highly recommend it. We also bought a hamburger bee that we haven't tried yet, but I'm confident it will be amazing. If it's not, I'll come back and update my review.
The best cherry cake I've ever had—seriously, EVER! I highly recommend it. We also bought a hamburger that we haven't tried yet, but I’m sure it will be amazing. If it turns out otherwise, I'll come back and update my review!
Awesome blackberry pie. Family is visiting and we wanted the worlds best blackberry pie. Pie Goddess me the need. Visiting family and other guests are amazed. There will be a slice for breakfast tomorrow. Wonderful.
By far the best cake I've ever had. My family and are new in the community and we loved that we happen on this little jewel in downtown Enumclaw.
I had a wonderful first experience at this restaurant. I ordered the dinner special and was impressed by both the generous portion size and the quality of the food. The service was also very nice.
