Pie Goddess - Enumclaw

#29 - Pizza - Enumclaw, Canadian, North American
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Pie Goddess

Pie Goddess
4.2 / 5 (1935 reviews)

Menu

The menu of Pie Goddess from Enumclaw includes 98 menus. On average the menus or drinks on the menu cost approximately $20.3. You can view the categories on the menu below.

Come try our selection of delicious pies by the slice such as Lemon Lush, Chocolate Lush, Butterscotch Lush, Peanut Butterfinger, Jumbleberry, Marionberry, Peach Pecan Crunch, Cherry Almond Crunch, Apple Walnut Crunch, and Toll House.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: User

Images

Pie Goddess Food Pie Goddess Food Pie Goddess Outside Pie Goddess Inside Pie Goddess Inside Pie Goddess Menu Pie Goddess Menu Pie Goddess Inside

Feedback

★ 4.2 / 5 from 1935 reviews

The Pie Goddess in Enumclaw garners mixed reviews, reflecting a fluctuating quality and charm. Longtime fans reminisce about unforgettable flavors, such as the butterscotch lush and blackberry pie, while some recent patrons lament the disappointing crusts and lackluster fillings, like the overly salty beef curry pie and bland chocolate cream. Despite its dedicated following, new ownership may have impacted consistency. Still, many believe the bakery's savory and dessert offerings, including chicken pot pie and various fruity delights, are worth the journey. Visitors are encouraged to try for themselves, as opinions vary widely on this beloved pie shop.

melissa-w-chef3739
06.11.2023

The quality has truly declined; the pies appeared barely baked with a pale, doughy crust. It's such a disappointment to witness this local gem deteriorate so much.

karen-marcotte
06.11.2023

OMG this delectable place makes the best Pies. One person works so please be patient. We got a chocolate raspberry pie that was to die for.

michael-l-firefighte-7
06.11.2023

They didn't have a Coconut Cream Pie available, which is my favorite for my birthday, but they made one for me while we waited. It was excellent—thank you so much!

I tried the banana cream pie. I took one bite and immediately spit it out, no idea what it was but I definitely didn't taste anything sweet. Texture was gross, not like any banana cream pie I've had before. Unfortunately disappointing :

THE place for fresh and delicious pies! We've had the Shepherds pies, berry pies, and specialty pies with no regrets. Less budget friendly than supermarket bakery pies but not even in the same category for comparison. You get what you pay for here.

  • Pie

    Dinner Dessert Special
    Dinner Dessert Special
    $35.0
  • Dessert

    Pie By The Slice
    Pie By The Slice
    $5.5
    Pie A La Mode
    Pie A La Mode
    $6.5
  • Savory Pies

    Spicy Beef Curry Pot Pie
    Spicy Beef Curry Pot Pie
  • Cream Pies

    Coconut-Eggnog Cream
    Coconut-Eggnog Cream

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.