Horatio's Homemade Ice Cream - Feedback

The ice cream cone was soggy and stale, and I regretted getting the chocolate chip cookie. I would advise against getting it as well, as it tasted old. After my...

The ice cream at this restaurant is really good! I loved the straightforward menu. The staff was nice, friendly, and clean. The atmosphere was clean, but it was...

The service was excellent and the ice cream was delicious. We will definitely be back next time we are in Custer.

The cone was soggy/stale and I made the mistake of getting the chocolate chip cookie. Don’t do that. It tasted like last week.Update: my family convinced me to...

This was the best ice cream I have tasted in a LONG time! Great friendly people and creamy rich great tasting ice cream. This is a MUST visit!

I really enjoyed the Berry Good Taste restaurant. As the name suggests, the food was delicious. I believe the ice cream was made with a coconut base.

I was pleasantly surprised to discover vegan options at this seemingly remote location. I tried the Hawaiian option, which consisted of coconut with pineapple a...

We ordered the mango coconut non-dairy ice cream, which was not a sorbet and was delicious.

I had not expected to find any vegan options in what seemed to be the middle of nothing. You had an option, Hawaiian. It's coconut with pineapple and cherry. It...

We had a dish of Mango coconut-not-dairy ice cream. That was definitely not a sorbet and really good.

I was not expecting to find any vegan options in what seemed to be the middle of nowhere. They had one option, Hawaiian. It is coconut based with pineapple and...

The non-dairy flavor is currently banana coconut and it is delicious! However, please note that the cones are not vegan-friendly.

We tried the mango coconut non-dairy ice cream and it was delicious. It was not a sorbet, but still really tasty.

I ordered the Berry Good flavor and, true to its name, it was delicious. I think it was made with a coconut-based ice cream.

Closed on Tuesday Wednesday