Route 9 Pizza - Cold Spring

If I could give this place zero stars, I would. I picked up what turned out to be the worst meal I've ever had. I planned to share a chicken cutlet wrap and a c... read more If I could give this place zero stars, I would. I picked up what turned out to be the worst meal I've ever had. I planned to share a chicken cutlet wrap and a calzone, but most of the food ended up in the trash. The calzone, filled with sausage and peppers, was completely tasteless. The cheese was rubbery, the sausage was sliced way too thin, and the peppers were thick—yet there was no flavor whatsoever. The wrap had diced roasted red peppers and diced chicken cutlet, which kept falling out, along with more of that rubbery cheese, and again, no flavor at all. The fries were alright, but everything else was a huge disappointment.

Delicious, high-quality food with quick and friendly service. I had the breaded chicken wrap for lunch, and it came with crispy fries. read more Delicious, high-quality food with quick and friendly service. I had the breaded chicken wrap for lunch, and it came with crispy fries.

I absolutely adore Route 9 Pizza! Whenever I stay at the Countryside Motel just across the street, I always make it a point to order from this restaurant at lea... read more I absolutely adore Route 9 Pizza! Whenever I stay at the Countryside Motel just across the street, I always make it a point to order from this restaurant at least once. The food is amazing, the prices are reasonable, and the customer service is exceptional. I can't wait to eat there again soon!

The portions were generous, and the taste surpassed my expectations given the price. I will definitely stop by again on our way back from the Fishkill Walmart. read more The portions were generous, and the taste surpassed my expectations given the price. I will definitely stop by again on our way back from the Fishkill Walmart.

I cannot recommend this restaurant at all! The pizza was excessively soggy and loaded with grease. The overall quality of the food was disappointing. Additional... read more I cannot recommend this restaurant at all! The pizza was excessively soggy and loaded with grease. The overall quality of the food was disappointing. Additionally, two out of the three staff members were rude, had poor communication skills, and seemed oblivious to the fact that customers noticed their behavior. I would highly advise you to avoid this place.