Nicola's Italian And Catering

The best Italian food in the style of New York I've ever had. My family lives in one of the cabins behind the restaurant for 4 months back in 1982. I visited there several times and Nick always pulls a fresh pan from Lasagne from the stove. So glad the restaurant is still in business. There's a story with the building. A very unique experience when you dive. Thanks Nick Madeline.

The food is excellent. The atmosphere is nice. The portions are large. The staff is friendly. Definitely worth it. Would go back again.

The restaurant must address the issue of their intoxicated waitress with blonde highlights. She approached our table at the end of our meal and made inappropriate and unfounded accusations against my fiancé. This behavior is unacceptable and reflects poorly on the establishment. The quality of the food is overshadowed by the unprofessional actions of their staff. We will not be returning to this restaurant due to their negligence in allowing their employees to mistreat customers while under the influence. It was a truly disappointing experience.

This restaurant is fantastic, I learned a lot about the people, facts, and history while I was there.

The food was excellent with fresh, generous portions. The atmosphere was cozy as well.