Reviews

Overall Total Score
4.7 out of 5
Outstanding | 4485 reviews

What Kate likes about Cape May Peanut Butter Co.:
Seems like they have awesome peanut butter and flavors of such. However we just got a cookie and scone here but they were pretty dry so I wouldn’t recommend getting their baked goods. Service was also not incredibly friendly View all feedback. What Marjorie Oquendo doesn't like about Cape May Peanut Butter Co.:
The peanut butter products are excellent, and I enjoy purchasing them in person in the charming town of Smithville. However, the staff at the store always appear to be annoyed, which makes for an unpleasant experience. It would be beneficial for them to improve their customer service or consider shutting down. View all feedback.

Reviews from various websites

Gastroranking-it
4.4 ★ from 50 reviews
Robin
05.10.2024 - 08:17

Tons of peanut butter based products and combination products. I got some tea I can't wait to try. The cookies were fantastic. They have jams, nut butters, drin...

read more
MidlandsTraveller
05.10.2024 - 08:17

Selling all things peanut butter related, but we were disappointed that there was no coffee available (it had apparently ”finished” and that there was little th...

read more
Dawn
05.10.2024 - 08:17

You can sample before you purchase. Workers at the store are super friendly. What a nice experience.

steve
05.10.2024 - 08:17

I believe that this peanut butter is the best of all of them.

Anirish
05.10.2024 - 08:17

Awesome choices of peanut butter are they give samples to taste lots of variety very friendly staff

Tucked away in the charming town of Smithville, the specialty peanut butter shop has garnered attention for its impressive array of delicious peanut butter products. While many customers rave about the unique flavors—especially the butterscotch—some have expressed disappointment in the cookie selection, noting they can be hard and stale. The cozy atmosphere is complemented by a lovely backyard patio, enhancing the shopping experience. However, customer service has come under scrutiny, with reports of unfriendly staff and slow refunds. Despite these setbacks, the shop remains a beloved stop for peanut butter aficionados, drawing loyal visits year after year.

Google
2.6 ★ from 10 reviews
Marjorie
27.10.2023 - 12:01

The peanut butter products are excellent, and I enjoy purchasing them in person in the charming town of Smithville. However, the staff at the store always appea...

read more
William
27.10.2023 - 12:01

"I had a fantastic experience trying all of their cookies ... they were delicious!"

Peace
27.10.2023 - 12:01

Very rude staff, walked out. Tried a few times to go in , thought well maybe just a bad day ! Seems like they have a lot of bad days!!! Seemed like you were bot...

read more
Dana
27.10.2023 - 12:01

Cookies are DRY as a desert. Do not let the smell of this place fool you. Are they serving cookies that are days old?? There’s no reason why the cookies should...

read more
Trevor
27.10.2023 - 12:01

Cookies in the case are hard as a rock. Peanut butter is good though. Bought some cookies though hard as a rock asked for refund and still haven’t received it....

read more
Menu
5.0 ★ from 5 reviews
বরকত
14.04.2022 - 20:39

As from england we have not much to choose in the type of erdnussbutter, so as a friend recommended this place, we could not wait to get there. I'm sure it wasn...

read more
Johnny
14.04.2022 - 20:39

I love this place the best erdnus butter that is there. oh and the erdnussbutter cannolis omgggggggggggggg celly. I have my repair today. Thanks for always havi...

read more
Magnolia
30.12.2022 - 06:55

Big personal we had a delicious hot kakao with the works!

Leanna
02.06.2022 - 13:10

Love this place probably because I love peanut butter. cookies are good and everything else

Tyrel
02.06.2022 - 13:10

Great erdnussbutter aromen and jelly variety. my faves are honey roasted pb the pfirsich amaretto gele. wonderful bakery!

Restaurantji
4.4 ★ from 311 reviews
Jeanne
16.10.2024 - 07:00

Great cookies and assortment of nut butters ! Cozy little shop with a very nice personality

Tracylee
16.10.2024 - 07:00

It tasted good, but it was very expensive. The hot chocolate was just ok. Chocolate was good. Wheelchair accessibility: For the most part, Cape May is not wheel...

read more
Marc
16.10.2024 - 07:00

Offering a tasty product

BrittStoff
16.10.2024 - 07:00

Delicious, excellent staff!

Restaurantguru
4.7 ★ from 1604 reviews
Int Restaurants
4.7 ★ from 1359 reviews
Gastroranking-us
4.6 ★ from 1211 reviews

Good Rated Restaurants near CAPE MAY

4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: CAPE MAY, 322 Washington Street Cape May, NJ 08204, 08204-1465, CAPE MAY, United States
"Best place to eat in Cape May! Great food and service!"
4.9
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.9
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: CAPE MAY, 315 Ocean St, Cape May I-08204-2340, United States, CAPE MAY
"The best coffee in town no contest. Great people. Better beans."
4.6
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.6
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: CAPE MAY, 1301 Beach Avenue, Cape May, 08204, United States Of America, 08204-2700, CAPE MAY
"Great food and service priced right. We will be back."
4.6
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.6
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: CAPE MAY, 314 Beach AveNJ 08204, CAPE MAY, United States
"Excellent service and wonderful food"
4.3
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.3
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: CAPE MAY, 416 South Broadway West Cape May, NJ 08204, 08204-5307, CAPE MAY, United States
"Entries, all are delicious, great place to dine."
4.3
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.3
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: CAPE MAY, 991 Ocean DrNJ 08204, CAPE MAY, United States
"Food portions were generous, served hot. Knowledgeable waitstaff"
4.5
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.5
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: CAPE MAY, 106 Decatur StreetNJ 08204, CAPE MAY, United States
"Very glad to see it continuing to live up to past great food"
4.6
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.6
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: CAPE MAY, 25 Jackson St, Cape May, United States Of America, CAPE MAY
"Food was fresh and delicious . Wait staff was very attentive."
4.5
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.5
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: CAPE MAY, 314 Beach Ave Cape May, NJ 08204, 08204-1921, CAPE MAY, United States
"Excellent as always! Tuna starter is always a must!"
4.4
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.4
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: CAPE MAY, 410 Bank StreetNJ 08204, CAPE MAY, United States
"Our favorite restaurant at the Shore for nearly 30 years."