Reviews
What Glenn doesn't like about Sea Shore Restaurant & Marina:
City Island is a place you never heard of but will be happy when you do and stop by for a nice meal. Bordering Pelham Bay Park, it makes for a nice outing. The waterfront location is delightful and the food and service was good. An extra star for getting bread and a small plate of cheeses and olives and other treats and having our drink order taken very quickly! Service was attentive, but either short staffed (so com... View all feedback. What STEPHENS likes about Sea Shore Restaurant & Marina:
This is one of our favorite restaurants on City Island. Service is excellent, food is delicious and plentiful. We had enough leftovers for a second dinner at home. Prices are reasonable for City Island seafood restaurants. View all feedback.
Reviews from various websites
We grew up in the bronx and have not been on the city island for over 30 years. we were there to celebrate the birthday of my husband and our high-time annivers...
read moreThe place was ok service was terrible. sat almost 20 minutes before a waiter came to see if we were helped.
I love sitting outside at the railing overlooking the water. The food is good though rather expensive. You are paying for the view! Service is spotty. Sometimes...
read moreWaiter was fine, could use more staff on the floor for a Saturday night.
Lobster tails were delicious. Love the house salad with the shrimp. We requested a change of table due to the wind off the water and were easily accommodated.
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreCity Island is a hidden gem that offers a delightful waterfront dining experience. While the restaurant may be a bit pricey and lacking in lunch options, the service is attentive and the food is good overall. The complimentary bread and small plate of cheeses add a nice touch to the meal. On the other hand, Sea Shore restaurant received negative feedback for oily antipasto and burnt marinara sauce. Limited selection and poor quality dishes left diners disappointed, especially during special occasions like birthdays. However, there were instances where the service stood out, with friendly staff and accommodating waiters making the dining experience enjoyable. The beautiful outdoor garden area and attentive service at City Island make it a top choice for many visitors, even though some wished for more menu variety like chicken dishes. Overall, the restaurant is recommended for those looking to enjoy a special occasion with fantastic service and a pleasant ambiance.
Exceptional every single time. Good and staff. Our favorite place! Came wait to be back.
The Wait staff is wonderful and the food even more so! The salmon is outstanding and the halibut was fresh and cooked perfectly. The views are always great
Beautiful setting, perfect for sunset dinner. Excellent 4 course fix price meal. Friendly and attentive service
Excellent across the board. Service was spot on and food was perfect. Great view of the harbor. Free valet parking was a big plus and the attendant was great.
Excellent food and service Reasonable prices. All in all a great meal
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreThe indoor space is comfortable and inviting, but the food falls short of satisfying standards. There is ample room for improvement in the taste of the food. Ho...
read moreCame here for a birthday and was so happy to see the table set with balloons, so sweet! While the food was great, can't say the same about our waiter. It seems...
read moreMy coworkers got together at this seafood restaurant, I don't eat seafood but I wanted to be in the reunion, they also served bbq ribs and chicken so I ordered...
read moreDelightful, best way that describes the meal drinks ' an dessert!
Not the most flavorful food....decent drinks and excellent service always. Classic City Island scene!
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreThe food was amazing and staff phenomenal! This was my 3rd time there, but it was the first time for my wife and 2 friends. My Wife said this is now her #1 favo...
read moreA dependable restaurant for many years. Always good, always pleasant staff, always each to enjoy a great meal.
The service and food was excellent the only disappointment was I ordered my dessert and there was no coffee how hard is it to put a pot of coffee on, I also wan...
read moreLovely dinner with family. Beautiful view, friendly staff, and relaxing atmosphere
City Island is a place you never heard of but will be happy when you do and stop by for a nice meal. Bordering Pelham Bay Park, it makes for a nice outing. The...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreAs we arrived to the restaurant we were first greeted by the friendly Valet personnel who directed our party inside the restaurant. The hostess guided us to the...
read moreWonderful place to eat! Everything was great from valet to our table outside with a decent view. Everyone and I mean everyone we encountered here was friendly a...
read moreThe food was good! I think there was about seven birthdays in one night but the service wasn’t bad At all.. bring a sweater it’s a little chilly! My booth had a...
read moreParking available.... beautiful little outdoor garden area, spacious and clean dining... great viewing.. Attentive service, friendly staff...best place I have b...
read moreBig group dinner with friends and family. Great spot for seafood. We ordered the seafood platter for 2. It's a lot of food and can definitely be shared with mor...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreI ordered the Seafood Feast, which was enough for 3 adults and 2 children. The crab was incredible and the lobster was packed with flavor and never failed to di...
read moreSea Shore restaurant is an excellent dining spot. The food was scrumptious, the service was good, and the atmosphere was pleasant. I would definitely recommend...
read moreI met up with some friends and we decided to have a gathering by the seaside. The restaurant had a nice atmosphere and the ambiance was quite lovely.
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read more