Peter Pan Diner - Bay Shore

Most of the Sundays morning I order family breakfast and I have never had any issues the order is always on point they really take time to read your order and follow the instructions, the the cashier guy even call me by my name is something so simple but it cheers me up every time, also very the restaurant is very clean. I just move from bayshore but I will drive 30 minutes to get my home fries ?

The best diner! Clean, efficient, friendly. Has everything you'd expect and more from a diner. Corned beef hash at breakfast was perfect and not greasy at all. Food well prepared and presented. Our server, sorry, I didn't get her name, but she was excellent. The manager was friendly and professional, and dressed in a crisp tailored shirt. There were two birthdays and they were prepared with a recorded song that everyone sang to. I would definitely recommend this place.

Always good food, friendly serviceParking: Plenty of parkingKid-friendliness: Good for familiesWheelchair accessibility: Wheelchair parking spots and ramp into diner

This has quickly become my go-to spot! The staff is so warm and accommodating, it’s like going to a to a friend’s home rather than an eatery! The food is delicious. My favorite is the Original Patty Melt with Russian dressing. It’s absolutely fantastic.

The food was good but the milkshakes were terrible. Watery and flavorless